Brown University

Brown University

Chuyn/Getty Images

Capital Pool

Universities’ dwindling financial positions place pressure on endowments

Slipping credit outlooks for Brown and Columbia reflect monetary constraints on top-tier higher education, and endowments are ill-prepared to help.
Brown University

Brown University

Chuyn/Getty Images

The credit ratings of some elite US universities are slipping, as financial constraints hit schools at the top of the ratings scale.

Endowment returns aren’t the primary driver of the credit rating downgrades seen in recent weeks, but their high exposure to illiquid assets could hurt their ability to supplement a school’s operating expenses at a time of increasing need.

Earlier this month, Moody’s Ratings revised Brown University‘s credit rating outlook to negative from stable, citing the weakening of already-thin operating performance amid rising expenses and financial aid commitments. Currently, the school has an Aa1 rating, the second-highest that Moody’s offers, but is at risk of a downgrade if Brown doesn’t improve its financial position.

The move marks a shift in the credit viability of the top private colleges and universities in the US.

Historically, most downgrade actions occurred at institutions with an A rating, the third-highest credit quality tier, or below.

But a slowdown in funding after the Trump administration’s efforts to cut federal research grants to top universities, paired with declining international enrollment pipelines and a softening in endowment spending power, has left even the institutions with high credit ratings vulnerable to downgrade.

In May, Moody’s revised Columbia University‘s outlook to negative for similar reasons: declining operating performance paired with the federal government’s giant sledgehammer to higher-education funding. For FY 2025, Columbia’s ratio of total cash and investments to operating expenses, a key metric underpinning its rating, was 2.7x, well below the median 10.7x for private universities with the same bond rating.

In March last year, the Trump administration canceled $400 million in federal funds to the university. While Columbia struck a deal with the federal government four months later to restore funding, the freeze stymied growth from grant revenue and required the New York school to reallocate a portion of its unrestricted endowment to provide temporary support to research projects that lost funding.

“All of these factors are coming to bear in what is a pretty unusual amount of pressure for schools that are typically not facing pressure like this,” said Emily Wadhwani, a senior director and sector lead for the higher education and nonprofit group at Fitch Ratings.

Universities rely on their endowments to support a portion of their operating budgets. In FY 2025, universities used their endowments to fund 15.2% of their annual operating expenses, according to data from the National Association of College and University Business Officers (NACUBO) and investment manager Commonfund.

In FY 2025, Brown’s endowment contributed $352 million to university operating, representing 23.3% of the school’s total revenue, underscoring how reliant the Rhode Island institution has become on endowment payouts relative to its peers.

Columbia’s financials paint a similar picture. The university’s $20.5 billion endowment reported that its operating surplus fell from $304.7 million in FY 2024 to $112.6 million in FY 2025, as operating expenses rose 5.3% and outpaced the 2.1% increase in operating revenue.

University President Claire Shipman called the surplus “low by historical standards,” the Columbia Spectator reported.

This is happening as endowments transition from years of strong earnings into a more muted period, particularly on the private markets side, where a prolonged drought in distributions is impacting their capacity to support university operations.

Sign up for Capital Pool

Weekly commentary on what’s driving LP decision-making, with senior funds columnist Jessica Hamlin.

With less cash on hand, endowments may be compelled to sell assets they don’t want to fund these obligations.

“It’s plausible that if you have more illiquidity than you planned, you might have to sell an active manager or trim one that you didn’t want to,” said Anne Duggan, co-head of custom asset allocation at TIFF Investment Management, an institutional consulting firm and outsourced CIO.

The illiquidity of endowments is a more immediate concern for universities, forcing schools to seek external funding sources for ready cash, said Wadhwani of Fitch.

“We’ve seen schools last year tap the taxable debt market for ready liquidity, use lines of credit, revolving lines of credit and commercial paper programs for ready liquidity,” she said.

That illiquidity squeeze is showing up in how universities manage their private markets exposure, not just their balance sheets. Endowments have historically leaned on PE and VC for outperformance, but those allocations are the hardest to convert to cash on short notice.

Wadhwani said she wouldn’t be surprised to see more outlook demotions, and potentially some downgrades, at top-rated universities in the coming months. However, she still expected the bulk of actions to remain concentrated at schools with A ratings or below.

Learn about our editorial standards.