The credit quality of US middle market CLOs has weakened due to liquidity erosion over the past year, but remains stronger than it was before the Covid pandemic, according to Moody’s.
In a report published May 12 titled “Smallest of middle market CLO borrowers remain most vulnerable to downturn,” Moody’s compared the credit metrics and credit estimates of 151 borrowers it reassessed in the second half of 2024 with their credit metrics and credit estimates from the second half of 2023.
Moody’s observed that the share of borrowers with “good” and “adequate” liquidity assessments had declined, while the share of borrowers with what Moody’s deems “weak” liquidity has increased to about 25% of borrowers, from about 18% the prior year.
“Despite moderate revenue growth from 2023 to 2024, this liquidity erosion comes after years of relatively poor financial performance and high interest expenses that have led businesses to deplete cash reserves,” analysts wrote.
According to the report, cash-flow-to-debt and free-cash-flow-to-debt ratios have both declined among the middle market companies that Moody’s reassessed in the past year, to 4.7% from 5.8% and to 1.1% from 1.5%, respectively.
This decline in liquidity is more pronounced among smaller middle market borrowers, which Moody’s defines as those companies with less than $50 million of EBITDA. Moody’s notes that the share of smaller borrowers with “weak” liquidity increased to about 31% from about 20%, while the share of larger borrowers with “weak” liquidity increased only marginally to about 18% from about 15%. Larger borrowers, Moody’s says, have more diverse revenue streams and a tendency to have better access to capital for refinancing and investments, while also benefiting from more negotiating leverage with buyers and suppliers.
While most credit estimates were unchanged year-on-year, Moody’s lowered credit estimates for about 24% of the small borrowers it rates and raised only about 8% of them, compared to around 16% lower and 14% higher for larger borrowers.
However, the rating agency notes that borrowers have managed to maintain their interest coverage, which it says is roughly steady at around 1.6x, even as their leverage has increased to 6.5x from 5.5x, as a result of expected interest rate declines.
The liquidity erosion of middle market borrowers contrasts with only a slightly higher percentage of broadly syndicated loans with “weak” or “adequate” liquidity in April 2025 versus April 2024.
“Owing to their size, MM borrowers are inherently more vulnerable to rising expenses and economic shocks than BSL borrowers. BSL borrowers also likely have greater availability of external sources of financing and fewer near-term debt maturities,” the report says.
Despite the erosion in liquidity, overall, portfolio-level credit metrics have been largely stable, writes Moody’s, which deems that senior bonds are structured with credit enhancement sufficient to withstand a rise in WARF similar to that which accompanied the Covid-related downturn in 2020.
Middle market CLO portfolio credit quality remains stronger than it was before Covid, when the median WARF was 3827 (in Q4 2019). In the fourth quarter of 2024, the median WARF in middle market CLOs rated by Moody’s was 3751, down from 3830 in the fourth quarter of 2023.
Featured image by Clickhere/Getty Images
Learn about our editorial standards.