shutterstock-1100454056.jpg
Leveraged Loans

(Very) Deep Dive: Can 5,000 years of history suggest where rates are heading?

With the Federal Reserve on Nov. 2 raising the fed funds target rate by 75 basis points for the fourth time this year, and the US 10-year Treasury yielding around 4%, market watchers have been studying past interest rate moves for clues about where rates might be heading. The question is whether the thousands-of-years-long interest rate downtrend is now breaking.

With the Federal Reserve on Nov. 2 raising the fed funds target rate by 75 basis points for the fourth time this year, and the US 10-year Treasury yielding around 4%, market watchers have been studying past interest rate moves for clues about where rates might be heading.

Some previous periods invite scrutiny — the much higher interest rates of the 1970s-80s are a topic of discussion these days. But a much, much deeper dive into history shows that today’s rate regime might also resemble that of the Early Renaissance period, and before that the Greek and Roman eras (like we said, this is a very deep dive).

Very briefly, borrowing rates on loans have been steadily declining for 5,000 years, from typically 20% and higher during the three millennia before the Common Era, to under 5% by the 1700s. During that downward drift, global risk-free rates spiked strongly twice — in the late 1400s into the early 1500s when rates exceeded 20%, and in the early 1980s when 10-year US Treasury yields topped 15%, UK gilts exceeded 16% and French OATs climbed above 17%.

deep-dive-chart-1-700x261.jpg

Source: St. Louis Fed

That last spike, as central banks fought to tame inflation, culminated in 2014 when European Central Bank President Mario Draghi pushed interest rates into negative territory. As the markets tried to make sense of them, a PIMCO website helpfully declared that “holding bonds with a negative yield may still be rational…a negative yielding bond can generate a positive return if interest rates fall further.”

Draghi had his reasons, of course, but wrapping one’s head around the strategy of profiting as negative yields became more negative was daunting for investors who had never, in five thousand years, contemplated them before.

Now, with inflation roaring, negative nominal rates and yields are behind us, at least for a while. But does the current rate rise signal the end of the long-term downtrend and a return to rates that were more common over time?

Admittedly, today’s debt markets are vastly different from those of the past. Even comparison with the markets of the 1970s and 1980s may be apples to locomotives. Nonetheless, a tour of the past is interesting, if not fodder for conversation, for investors.

In the beginning
Note: Most sources employed in this commentary used directly or indirectly the following as their own sources: the book A History of Interest Rates by Sidney Homer and Richard Sylla (John Wiley & Sons, 1963); and the paper Eight Centuries of Global Real Interest Rates, R-G, and The ‘Suprasecular’ Decline, 1311-2018, by Paul Schmelzing (Staff Working Paper No. 845, Bank of England, 2020). This commentary also uses both as sources for historical data.

Of course, rates were not always as easy to calculate as they are today, in part because the nature of currency has changed, from physical assets such as fruit and cattle, to paper and coins, and now to lines of code. Before 3000 BC, for example, historians write of land being lent to farmers who paid the landowner interest and principal with the first fruits to come from that land.

Serfs and poor farmers borrowed seeds and nuts, with a larger portion of the next harvest due to the lender in return. While returning more than the quantity borrowed is undisputedly a “positive yield” to the capital provider, it’s pretty hard to compute a measurable interest rate from that.

deep-dive-chart-2b-500x340.jpg

The first rates that would look familiar to modern credit market players were recorded in Mesopotamia during the Sumerian period of around 3000-1900 BC, and then in the Babylonian period of 1900-732 BC (to be sure, sources don’t agree on the exact date range for these periods). Agricultural-based loans, such as of barley — which was borrowed and repaid, with the interest in barley as well — were often made at a rate of 33.3% per year, while silver loans were generally at 20% per annum (with some examples found at 25%).

In the Babylonian period, the Sumerian rates were generally considered maximums. This period saw barley loans between 20% and 33.3%, while silver was reportedly lent out at rates of 10-25%, with a low mark of 6.25%.

Loans during the Assyrian period (732-625 BC) were commonly made without interest, though with late penalties ranging between 40% and 141%. Still, examples of interest charges exist at rates that included silver loans at 25-40% and grain loans at rates as high as 50%.

Skipping across the Aegean, rates in Greece for borrowing silver in the 500s BC ranged from around 16-18% for unsecured loans, to 8-12% for silver loans collateralized by real estate. By 300 BC Greek lending rates generally declined to 10% and below.

A significant exception to relatively low Greek rates were “sea loans,” or bottomry loans, secured by a ship or its cargo. Those rates were around 22% for peacetime voyages and 30% during wartime, though they reportedly reached 100% for more hazardous or longer trips.

In the Roman Republic in the 300s BC, loan rates were generally capped at one-twelfth, or 8.33% per Roman pound of whatever was being lent. Soon, that rate was cut in half, and then to zero, to spur the economy. But by the first century BC, a 12% interest rate cap was instituted throughout Rome. Six hundred years later, rates under Roman emperor Justinian (ruled 527–565 AD) were reduced again, this time to roughly 4-8%. The top end was then lifted in the 800s AD to 11.125%.

Risk-free
With money-lending’s rising sophistication and improved documentation beginning around 700 years ago, financial historians have identified safe, or what today would be considered “risk-free,” lending rates of the leading municipalities and countries since the beginning of the Renaissance Period. They have delineated blocks of time between the 1300s and today where one city-state or country dominated commercially, and often militarily as well, giving merchants reason to concentrate their capital in that locality. For their time they were, perhaps, the closest thing to a risk-free rate setter.

With the exception of the late-15th century’s rate spike, nominal rates continued the downward trend that began with the Babylonians. Real rates, defined by the Fisher Effect as nominal rates minus inflation, also exhibited a steady decline since the early 1500s, revealing a long-term inflation rate that would be the envy of central banks today.

deep-dive-4b-500x341.jpg

The last 700 years
Italy was an economically pivotal European country in the 14th and 15th centuries. At the time, Venetian debt was “treated as the most advanced sovereign debt market, while Florence, home of the Medici bank, is frequently considered the leader in private, commercial markets,” according to sources cited by Boston College finance professor Paul Schmelzing (see note above).

Loan rates in the 1300s averaged 7.3% and in the 1400s, 11.2%. Subtracting inflation (the Fisher Effect) resulted in real rates of 5.1% and 9.1% in the 1300s and 1400s, respectively. The rate spike during the 15th century’s second half, when borrowers saw rates in the low-20% range, was attributed to various causes including the fall of Constantinople and the end of the Byzantine Empire, Ottoman Empire battles for Balkan silver mines, and warring Italian city-states.

In the 1500s, Spain’s seafaring explorers founded colonies in the New World and the country’s wealth multiplied. In that 100-year period, the centennial loan average rate was 7.8% before inflation, and the real rate was 6.1%.

The Netherlands succeeded Spain as the commercial center after King Philip II died in 1598. In the 1600s, the country and its Bank of Amsterdam saw lending rates average 5.4%. Inflation ran at less than half the rate of the previous 300 years, producing a 4.6% real interest rate. The Tulip Craze is proof of the Dutch domination of European finance, as detailed by Businessinsider.com, Only in a market with significant surplus capital could speculation run so rampant, a circumstance perhaps not dissimilar to the recent investing environment.

Britain dominated finance in the 1700s and 1800s, riding the Industrial Revolution, which began in that country, as its citizens invented textile machinery, iron-producing processes and steam power, among other things. The dominant security in the market were British consols, consolidated 3.5% annuities (later reduced to 3% and then to around 2.5%).

Average European risk-free rates were 4.1% in the 1700s and 3.5% in the 1800s. Inflation was particularly tame, averaging only 0.6% in the 1700s and near 0% in the 1800s, resulting in a real average interest rate of 3.5% and 3.4% in the 18th and 19th century, respectively.

The US became the world’s superpower and simultaneously took over as the center for global finance in the early 20th century. The twentieth century’s average nominal interest rate was 5.0% but that includes the 31-year period of 1967-1998 when the US 10-year Treasury yield never dropped under 5%. Inflation averaged 3.1%, elevated by the exceptional inflation periods of 1946-1947 and 1973-1982, which pushed the real rate of interest down to 2.0%.

Finally, in the first two decades of the 21st century, risk-free rates have averaged 3.5%, while inflation came in at around 2.2%, taking the stub-period’s real rate to 1.3%.

The average safe, or risk-free, rate since the 1300s is 6.3%, according to Schmelzing, a figure pushed upward by the rate spikes in the 1400s and 1900s. Highlighting the long-term downward rate trend, Schmelzing computed the average nominal rate over the most recent two hundred years at 4.2%, 210 bps under the 800-year average.

The downtrend can also be seen in real rates. The average real rate since the 1300s is 4.8%, while the real rate over the past 200 years is 220 bps less, at 2.6%, Schmelzing wrote.

Breaking bad
Will the current central-bank-driven rise in rates level off somewhere near Schmelzing’s long-term mean before resuming the long downtrend, or will this mark the end of the millennia-long decline as interest rates plateau somewhere higher?

Recent reports have analysts now expecting the Fed to halt its rate hikes at a 5% fed funds target, although reaction to last week’s Fed meeting and follow-up presser suggests that rates might go higher. That’s 100 bps above today’s level and roughly 25% above Schmelzing’s average nominal “risk free” rate over the past 200 years. A positively sloped yield curve would then put the US 10-year Treasury yield close to Schmelzing’s 800-year nominal average of 6.3%.

Rates being so far above the long-term downtrend might normally suggest the trendline’s demise, except that we saw this movie roughly 40 years ago, when rates and yields spiked into double-digits before turning tail. And until recently it certainly seemed that the super-long-running downtrend had resumed, particularly when European yields dropped under the zero bound. This relatively recent history implies that the downtrend could soon pick up again right where it left off.

Trendlines inevitably break. The question before investors is whether the thousands-of-years-long interest rate downtrend is breaking now.

Featured image by zef art/Shutterstock

Learn about our editorial standards.