A four-page piece of legislation that passed through the US House of Representatives on July 21 calls on the SEC to revise the definition of “accredited investor” from high-net-worth individuals to anyone who passes a federally mandated exam.
It’s not a done deal yet, but the bill would make becoming an investor in PE or VC as easy as getting a learner’s permit. OK, maybe a bit more rigorous.
The legislation, which still needs Senate approval, would require the SEC to create an exam—whether a test or certification—within a year of becoming law. The exam would, according to the bill, ensure test-takers understand the types of securities offered on the private market and comprehend concepts like corporate governance, components of financial statements and risks associated with common attributes of a private market investment: limited liquidity, little information, opaque valuation techniques and longer-term investment horizons.
The bill draws on the decades-long debate about which investors should have access to private companies as the private market fund industry makes deeper inroads with individual investors.
Spearheaded by Delaware’s only state congressional representative, Sarah McBride, the act gained bipartisan support for its purpose of providing access to the private markets to people who don’t meet the current federally mandated threshold of a net worth of over $1 million or an annual income of over $200,000. Reps. Mike Flood (R-NE), Mike Lawler (R-NY) and Cleo Fields (D-LA) co-signed the legislation.
Subscribe to the newsletter here
“Our bill will unlock capital for entrepreneurs and small business owners who’ve been left out for far too long,” Rep. McBride said in a statement. “Current law allows only millionaires to invest in private markets—shutting out countless Americans, especially women, veterans, and people of color, based on wealth, not knowledge.”
The definition of an accredited investor is a topic of widespread debate in the private funds regulatory space. Parties argue that legislation broadening the definition needs to strike a balance between protecting investors and providing access to individuals who may not otherwise have access to the private markets.
Related: Larry Fink pushes for wealthy investors’ dollars
“This [bill] feels less about something the industry lobbied for and more about addressing something that has troubled people for a long time,” said Aaron Schlaphoff, partner and head of investment management regulation at law firm Paul, Weiss. “There are lots of people who make $200,000 a year...or have a million dollars in net worth that are not financially sophisticated. At the same time, there are plenty of people who don’t have that level of income and wealth and are sophisticated.”
Industry groups like the CAIA Association have advocated for opening private markets beyond institutional investors through education initiatives.
“We’ve long felt that the narrow view of accredited that’s focused solely on wealth and income was no longer the only proxy for the ability to handle drawdown and sophistication and risk profile and opacity of alternative investments,” said John Bowman, CEO of the CAIA Association. Still, Bowman said CAIA strongly suggests that fiduciaries—private wealth advisers and 401(k) sponsors, for example—are involved in the process to dissuade everyday investors from taking on too much risk.
Winners and losers
Investment management regulation in the US is often reactive: A fund does something to harm its investors, the SEC investigates the misconduct, and, if the GP hasn’t violated an existing rule, the agency will create one—or try to.
This means that, ultimately, the risk of making the private markets accessible to anyone who can pass a test will first fall on private market managers themselves, said Amy Lynch, founder and president of FrontLine Compliance, a consultant to investment firms.
Money managers will begin offering products to newly qualified investors, prompting the SEC to examine these funds and crack down on excessive risk. This will lead to more regulation, she noted.
In the meantime, GPs will have to increase their due diligence and compliance around onboarding investors to avoid SEC scrutiny.
“There’s a due diligence process that investors go through, and it won’t be the simple check-the-box in the subscription documents that it is today,” said Lynch.
Even armed with bipartisan support, Schlaphoff doesn’t think the new entrants to the market through this bill would materially change the demographic makeup of PE’s investor base.
Additionally, asset managers with evergreen and perpetual capital products available to accredited investors are unlikely to lower their minimum entry fees, which would make the price to play untenable to most everyday investors, even those who ace the test, Lynch said.
“Everyone is competing for the same dollars,” Lynch said. “The private fund industry is trying to open up the universe of investors. But this particular bill, in my personal opinion, may not be the best way to approach it.”
Featured image by uschools/Getty Images
Learn about our editorial standards.