gettyimages-1300199147-rqv.jpg
Middle Market

Reporter’s notebook: M&A dealmakers rely on structured deals to close transactions

Middle-market private equity firms seeking high-quality assets are facing a crowded playing field as larger GPs hunt downstream amid tight lending conditions.

Middle-market private equity firms seeking high-quality assets are facing a crowded playing field as larger GPs hunt downstream amid tight lending conditions.

To close deals, financial buyers are finding creative ways to package financing and conducting due diligence early to reduce transaction risk, according to panelists speaking at an Association for Corporate Growth event in Seattle on Thursday.

Several said middle-market PE firms are under pressure to deploy capital in the face of increased competition from funds that traditionally target larger-sized deals.

acgimage.jpg

Panelists speak at the ACG Seattle conference
(Madeline Shi/PitchBook News)


“We are in the business of managing capital prudently on behalf of our LP investors, and there’s a lot of pressure for us to deploy capital,” said one speaker, Jamie Kim, who heads business development at Gallant Capital Partners, a middle-market PE firm based in Los Angeles.

“There is a real sort of fire to get something done and to find something to do,” she said.

Kim said her firm hasn’t done a platform acquisition since last December. “If you are a PE firm and you are not looking closely at something right now or soon, you may not make any investments in 2023,” Kim added in a follow-up interview.

Gallant, founded in 2018 by ex-Gores executives, primarily invests in the technology, business services and infrastructure sectors. It manages two buyout funds, according to PitchBook data.

Increased competition

One pressure facing the firm is a more crowded middle market. With debt financing getting more expensive and inaccessible, some larger funds are looking down market for deals and are willing to write larger equity checks to finance the transactions, putting more pressure on smaller managers.

That pileup of funds hunting for deals in the middle market has also increased competition for high-quality assets.

“If you are a good company with a defensible, strong balance sheet, it’s a crazy competitive market,” Kim said. “We are bidders, and we’re competing against 40 to 50 other bidders at the initial stage.”

Hesitant lenders

At the same time, bank lenders in the broadly syndicated loan market—traditionally an important engine for leveraged buyouts—still find it tougher to syndicate deals compared with several quarters ago, as investors’ appetite for risk has dwindled.

Brandon Kirkbride, Pacific Northwest credit executive at Bank of America, said that fewer lenders today are willing to fund large loan packages to support acquisitions.

About nine to 12 months ago, when Bank of America would invite other lenders to syndicate a loan, about 85% of invited lenders would typically join the deal, Kirkbride said. Today, however, only about 50% of invited lenders tend to participate.

Recently Kirkbride’s firm closed a large transaction to support an acquisition: It invited 44 banks to participate in the syndication, but only 24 joined, he said.

US banking authorities could further tighten the lending market and raise borrowing costs. In late July, regulators proposed stricter rules that could increase capital requirements for banks with more than $100 billion in assets. For the largest institutions, that could mean an increase of roughly 20% in capital reserves.

Creative deal structures

With large commercial banks holding back on funding mergers, direct lenders have stepped up and become the main source of debt for middle-market deals. Mezzanine debt also reemerged in recent months as buyers look to fill the financing gap.

In addition, to remedy a lack of cheap debt financing, buyers have come up with creative ways to structure deals, including a rising inclusion of seller notes and earnouts that defer a portion of deal proceeds to sellers, the panelists agreed.

Doing diligence early in the process can reduce transaction risk for sellers and advisers, and offer bidders a leg up when there is high demand and low supply for quality deals, said Cameron Hewes, who heads the North American mid-market M&A business at BMO Capital Markets.

The good news is, despite a string of unfavorable market conditions, dealmakers have found some relief in today’s environment.

The gap between sellers’ and buyers’ expectations for valuations has dissipated over the last few months, suggesting it will become easier for negotiators to agree on price, Hewes said.

Clarification
This story was updated with additional comment from Jamie Kim to clarify her remarks. (Aug. 8, 2023)

Featured image by tolgart/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.