Consensus 2019

Coinbase founder and CEO Brian Armstrong attends Consensus 2019 in New York City.

Featured image by Steven Ferdman/Getty Images

Cryptocurrency/Blockchain

Coinbase’s SEC win leaves a big crypto question unanswered

The crypto exchange said the SEC has agreed in principle to drop its lawsuit against the company. But uncertainty around crypto securities would remain.
Consensus 2019

Coinbase founder and CEO Brian Armstrong attends Consensus 2019 in New York City.

Steven Ferdman/Getty Images

The SEC’s proposed dismissal of its long-running lawsuit against Coinbase (announced on Friday by the company) has elicited cautious optimism from crypto-focused VCs.

The news is “a sign that the SEC under this administration is taking a much more constructive approach” to the industry, says Paul Hsu, founder and CEO of Decasonic, a VC firm focusing on blockchain investments. But even if the lawsuit is dismissed, the SEC’s unsettled securities determination has resulted in a “lack of clarity,” he says.

The SEC’s initial complaint in 2023 alleged that 13 crypto tokens trading on Coinbase’s exchange are unregistered securities, and thus illegally being traded. The move roiled liquid digital asset markets and placed startups with related dealings on uneven compliance ground.

That specific status quo for VCs and their crypto portfolio companies did not budge on Friday. However, general partners and other industry participants say the Trump administration SEC’s first major crypto move is a step in the right regulatory direction.

Whether US regulators ultimately designate crypto assets as securities, commodities or neither has substantial implications for venture-backed startups in that industry. Private US companies that facilitate crypto trading and lending, as well as firms engaged in market making and custody, have been especially exposed. Solana, a token that’s becoming hugely popular among US-based meme coin aficionados, was among those cited in the lawsuit.

Hoolie Tejwani, head of Coinbase Ventures, categorized Coinbase’s potential legal victory as a strong rebuttal to the SEC’s crypto enforcement actions under the Biden administration.

Tejwani calls the lawsuit’s dismissal—which is pending a vote by SEC commissioners—a “big win for the industry, for founders” and a reversal of “unlawful regulatory overreach.”

Crypto attention turns toward the Hill, IPOs

“We’re not done,” adds Tejwani. “Regulatory clarity is going to require legislation in Congress, and that’s where a lot of our energy and focus is going to go now.”

An SEC spokesperson declined to comment.

Two federal bills that would establish standards for stablecoins, as well as proposed legislation on digital asset market structure, are gaining attention.

The efforts could clarify the status of specific tokens, providing greater certainty to crypto startups and their VCs.

Coinbase’s stock was down 8.3% at market close on Friday. But the case’s potential dismissal is a positive signal for potential crypto IPO candidates, according to senior PitchBook analyst Robert Le. He expects the stock to rise once institutions restricted from buying shares during the lawsuit start buying again.

“The comps for all these publicly traded companies are going to be comped to Coinbase, and their valuations are going to go up as well,” says Le.

Alex Thorn, Galaxy Digital’s research head, says that “the SEC is not necessarily saying that the tokens in the lawsuits are not securities” if it indeed drops its suit. But the maneuver would indicate the regulator’s priorities of making securities classifications via rulemaking, not litigation, he adds.

Learn about our editorial standards.