popularity

Featured image by PM Images/Getty Images

Capital Pool

Drive for liquidity fuels greater adoption of controversial NAV loans

GPs and LPs are increasingly taking out NAV loans for liquidity despite historic scrutiny of the instrument.

Dealmakers report a notable uptick in the adoption of net-asset-value loans, signaling that the once-controversial tool is increasingly favored by GPs and LPs across private markets as investors face more pressing demands for liquidity.

Amid a slow M&A market and a prolonged exit dry spell, views on NAV loans appear to be changing.

“NAV facilities are in vogue now,” said Shana Ramirez, who heads the fund finance team at Katten Muchin Rosenman.

GPs typically take out NAV loans against a pool of assets within a fund to provide capital for new investments and support the growth of their portfolio companies. They can also use these loans to make early distributions to their LPs.

NAV loans have raised concerns in the past because they can raise unseen risks to LPs and mask the true health of a portfolio.

This article originally appeared in the Capital Pool newsletter. Subscribe to the newsletter here

In a sign of a possible shift, Ramirez said she has seen the issuance of new NAV facilities outpace new subscription credit lines, a striking trend given the latter’s long-standing dominance in the fund finance market. Sub-lines are another common tool used by GPs to access liquidity, but they are usually issued during fundraising, which has slowed.

Some investors who were previously skeptical of the instrument have become more receptive to them, agreeing to provisions in limited partner agreements (LPA) that permit the use of NAV financing, Ramirez told me.

In another sign of changing times, LPs including large pension funds, family offices and sovereign wealth funds are starting to use NAV facilities to free up cash without selling assets at unfavorable prices, the Financial Times reported in May.

An influx of new lenders

Investors’ greater receptivity has encouraged new entrants—both banks and non-bank lenders—to step into the NAV financing market over the last two years, leading to increased competition as well as more competitive pricing and terms.

For instance, Partners Group in early 2024 launched its dedicated NAV financing vehicle, while European private credit manager Pemberton held a first close for its NAV fund last June.

The increased financing options have bolstered borrowers’ negotiating power, allowing them to secure more favorable terms, such as competitive pricing, looser covenants and less stringent collateral requirements, according to Duncan McKay, a partner at Fried, Frank, Harris, Shriver & Jacobson advising sponsors on fund finance transactions.

Risks to LPs

This rising enthusiasm for NAV loans stands in contrast to the resistance seen two years ago.

A survey conducted by the Institutional Limited Partners Association (ILPA) in Q4 2024 found that 65% of LP respondents held a negative view of the widespread use of NAV-based facilities. While the respondents who expressed caution still represented the majority, their share fell from 85% in 2023, a figure cited by Jennifer Choi, the CEO of ILPA, in an interview with the Wall Street Journal.

If the value of the fund’s assets declines, leading to default on a loan, lenders can force repayment ahead of distributions to LPs.

NAV facilities may also introduce cross-collateralized risk to investors. While it may be cheaper to take out a NAV loan to support a portfolio, if an investment within the fund fails, lenders can seize proceeds from other strong-performing assets to recoup their losses, thus diluting returns for LPs.

Commenting on the recent rise of NAV loans, Brian Hoehn, director of industry affairs at ILPA, emphasized the need to maintain transparency.

“Leverage has always existed in the private equity market, and it’s critical for LPs and GPs alike to be transparent around the use of leverage,” he said.

He suggested GPs communicate clearly to LPs about the use of NAV loans and their inherent risks, and allow LPs to assess the risk and form a judgment by themselves.

Hoehn said LPs still largely prefer traditional exits to taking distributions from fund-level NAV loans, which bear interest costs and may dilute returns.

“A majority of our LPs are not in such dire straits—like this is not 2008 when LPs desperately needed cash back to fund their institutions,” he said. “Our LPs have been managing their internal liquidity well, so they can wait for traditional exits.”

Featured image by PM Images/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.