While rising interest rates in Europe since mid-2022 have benefited floating-rate assets, they raised the cost of financing to record levels and hampered private equity deal-making, in turn restricting the amount of new debt issuance available for credit investors. This followed a long period of unusually low interest rates which had proved favorable to private equity at the expense of private debt — though as the macro-economic outlook stabilized in recent months, signs of recovery are emerging amid optimism for a resurgence in M&A activity.

The knock-on effect of this dynamic for loan investors — which are often reliant on the private equity deal-making engine to source assets — was a fall in broadly syndicated loan (BSL) issuance from sponsor-backed borrowers in 2023 to €28.6 billion, which was the lowest such total since 2012, according to LCD. When stripping out deals other than buyouts (such as refinancings, recaps and other types of M&A), this tally falls to just €7.6 billion, the lowest since 2009 in the immediate aftermath of the GFC.
Green shoots
At the recent SuperReturn and IMN CLO conferences, the consensus among participants suggested new-issue M&A supply was going to make a healthy comeback, even if such issuance may not emerge in a meaningful way until the latter part of this year. As expectations for interest rates steadied in the opening phase of 2024, some green shoots started to emerge.
Looking at total broadly syndicated buyout transaction volume (which reflects total sources of funding for buyouts, including debt and equity), for example, this measure has increased to €16.3 billion in the last 12 months to the end of February, from €14.1 billion across 2023.

This new issuance has been bolstered by deals such as Eleda, which in February allocated its €918 million buyout by Bain, split between a €765 million term loan B and a €153 million delayed-draw TLB priced at E+450 with a 0% floor offered at 99.

Such activity comes after geopolitical conflicts, rising interest rates and rampant inflation had a dampening effect on private equity deal-making in 2023, as the cost of financing soared. As overheard by one delegate at a recent European conference: "Private equity is so last year, it’s all about private debt now."
Despite this depression in private equity deal value — which was down 26.5% in 2023 to the lowest such total in three years, according to PitchBook Data — sponsors were still able to source opportunities via smaller add-ons or buy-and-build strategies, as the corresponding deal count increased 4.4% in 2023.
The uncertainty present in markets over the past few years, coupled with the increased cost of debt, also means private equity funds have been more hesitant to deploy capital — a situation that has been exacerbated by a valuation mismatch between buyers and sellers.
Exit strategy
Meanwhile, as measured by the Morningstar European Leveraged Loan Index LBO (ELLI LBO), there has not been a full sponsored debt repayment by an IPO since 2020, while the average time to repayment increased to 75.6 months in February 2024, compared to almost half this number in 2021 (which was a refinancing-dominated year).

As a result of the subsequent drought in potential exits, private equity owners have been holding assets for longer. In turn, debt maturities which fund these investments have also been stretched, often through the use of amend-to-extend transactions.
However, European perfume and beauty retailer Douglas, which is owned by CVC and the Kreke family, in March completed its listing, which would — together with a €300 million equity contribution — raise roughly €1.1 billion to support deleveraging, including an early redemption of its secured notes and PIK bond. Despite the lacklustre performance in early trading as Douglas' shares fell as much as 9%, hope still remains that this deal will open a route for others to follow.
Indeed, Golden Goose, an Italy based fashion brand primarily known for its high-priced sneakers, is said to be working towards a Milan listing in the first half of this year — thereby providing an exit for sponsor Permira, which invested in the group in 2020. Another potential listing is HotelBeds, in which sponsors including Cinven and Canada Pension Plan Investment Board first invested back in 2016. Like Douglas, HotelBeds suffered during the pandemic, but has since recovered strongly in line with a rebound in travel demand.
Cost of debt
Another reason for the recent subdued period of sponsor-backed deal making is that the cost of debt has soared. Driven by the rise in interest rates, the average new-issue YTM for a single-B euro-denominated BSL term loan B reached 9.17% for the three months to the end of December 2023, according to LCD, which is the highest such reading on record. However, spreads on new-issue deals have tightened since the start of the year, driven by a repricing wave which first emerged in the US, taking the average spread from E+464 in the three months to end-December, down to E+423 at end-February (for an 8.53% YTM).

In anticipation, the leverage being put on newer BSL buyout deals has fallen to 4.82x in the last 12 months to end-February, the lowest since 2013, while the average equity cheque has increased slightly to 49%, which runs above the 2013-23 average of 45.9%.
Competition time
This picture of depressed issuance in the BSL market can also be partly attributed to increased competition from private credit deals, as sponsors have often favoured the certainty of execution promised by the private product over a syndicated deal, while private capital providers might be more comfortable offering higher turns of leverage.

However, thanks to the tightening in European loan spreads so far this year, the broadly syndicated asset class is looking more attractive again, with market commentators speculating the spread differential between a decent single-B borrower in the BSL and private markets could now be near to 200 bps. Looking at the count of European LBOs financed by direct lending versus the BSL market, the respective ratio here has fallen sharply this year — to 3:1 in the first quarter (to March 18) from 10:1 in Q4 2023, reflecting the challenge from banks and the competitive dynamic now in play.
Banks are also fighting back by offering more than just cost savings, including facilities such as delayed-draw term loans (as included on Eleda’s buyout). These features are not generally favoured by investors, but are mechanisms for sponsors to avoid raising add-ons at a later stage, and provide greater flexibility of capital.
One example of a private debt financing that went to the BSL market is April Insurance, which on March 6 priced a €1.2 billion term loan refinancing to take out a unitranche club from its buyout and support an acquisition. April was a previous and popular syndicated name, so it was a deal ripe for refinancing. “People have always liked that name,” confirmed a manager.
Other large borrowers that opted for private credit rather than the often dislocated syndicated product over the past couple of years are likely to follow these deals to market, subject to call protection, bankers say. However, bankers note that direct lenders are now reacting to the challenge, and are pre-emptively repricing deals lower in response to the renewed competitive threat.

Powder puff
Zooming back out to the big picture, a resumption in M&A activity is largely anticipated due to the huge amount of dry powder which private equity players need to put to work. According to PitchBook Data, the cumulative amount waiting to be deployed in PE buyout funds at the end of 2023 reached €365.2 billion, which is more than 2.5x the amount tracked ten years prior.
Despite this burgeoning optimism, there is also growing concern among investors in both syndicated and direct lending markets regarding potential defaults, which are expected to come from older-vintage deals which are not able to refinance easily into the higher interest-rate environment.
As one panelist at the SuperReturn conference commented, “there are some ugly looking cap tables out there."
That said, the share of the ELLI LBO index rated CCC and below is the lowest since 2018, so at least such signs of distress are not being observed materially in Europe's loan index just yet.

Sarayut Thaneerat/Getty Images
Learn about our editorial standards.