3d render chart bar diagram business growth concept and stock market sales strategy

Featured image by Muhammad Gunawansyah/Getty Images

Leveraged Loans

Leveraged loan default rate jumps as First Brands takes fast track to bankruptcy

The First Brands bankruptcy is the ninth-largest default in the history of the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index.

Want to see more? Fill out the form below.

I agree to PitchBook’s privacy policy

The speed of First Brands’ demise offered a stark reminder of idiosyncratic risk in the leveraged finance markets. Despite carrying a first-lien credit rating in the high single-Bs for most of last month, the automotive parts manufacturer on Sept. 29 filed for Chapter 11 protection, placing four facilities across the US and European loan indices into default.

While the speed and magnitude of losses was undoubtedly painful for investors — who per market feedback likely overweighted allocations to their benchmarks at the start of the month — the issuer’s footprint in the default landscape is less eye-popping. In the US, First Brands added 32 bps to the default rate and places ninth on the leaderboard for the top 10 largest defaults.

As of Sept. 30, the trailing 12-month default rates of the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index were as follows:

  • Payment default rate by amount: 1.47%
  • Payment default rate by issuer count: 1.47%
  • Dual-track default rate by issuer count: 4.32%

LCD’s monthly default report features the legacy payment default rate and a dual-track default rate by count that includes index issuers conducting distressed liability management exercises (LMEs). More details and the methodology can be found here.

Defaults 1.png

For conventional payment defaults (excluding distressed LMEs), First Brands and Astra (Anthology) joined the trailing-12-month calculation. With Digicel rolling off, the default rate by amount jumped to 1.47% in September, from 1.15% in August.

The default rate now stands at its highest level since January 2024.

By issuer count, the rate is also 1.47%, up from 1.36% in August.

Note that loan default rates reached post-pandemic peaks of 1.75% by amount in July 2023 and 2.07% by issuer count in February 2024 as the Fed’s extended period of rate hikes began to bite.

Defaults 2.png

When looking at the combined default rate to include distressed LMEs prompting a downgrade to ‘D’ or ‘SD’ last month, the dual-track rate eased slightly to 4.32% in September, from 4.37% in August (by issuer count).

Summit Behavioral Healthcare joined the issuer-count roll call, Pretium Packaging remains on account of its March 2025 default, while American Rock Salt Company, SI Group and Tosca Services left the calculation.

For reference, the recent high for the combined rate is 4.70% in December 2024.

In absolute terms, the trailing-12-month count of issuers in the Morningstar LSTA US Leveraged Loan Index conducting LME transactions fell to 31 in September, from 33 in August and 37 in July.

In September 2022, when the Federal Reserve was in a rate-hiking cycle, the trailing-12-month count for LMEs was just six.

Defaults 3.png

Liability management exercises and distressed exchanges have outpaced payment defaults and bankruptcies in every month on a rolling 12-month basis since January 2024, deviating from the historical norm for balance sheet management by distressed loan issuers.

Defaults 4.png

With the rapid rise in the use of LMEs to restructure since the pandemic, these types of transactions now make up 66% of default activity by count, versus 34% for conventional payment defaults. At the peak in July and February 2025, LMEs comprised 73% of the default landscape. In January 2020, at the start of the pandemic crisis, LMEs were just 9% of defaults.

Race to the bottom
Going from zero to 60 in a matter of seconds by restructuring standards, First Brands, a manufacturer and distributor of automotive brakes, filed for Chapter 11 in bankruptcy court in Houston.

Concerns began to mount after the company unsuccessfully pitched to refinance existing dollar and euro-denominated first-lien term loans totaling roughly $3.8 billion and €646 million, respectively, maturing in March 2027 — leaving limited time before the loans became current liabilities.

On Sept. 22, S&P Global Ratings and Moody’s both downgraded First Brands by multiple notches, with each agency citing rising refinancing risk and increasing odds of a debt restructuring.

S&P slashed First Brands by three notches to CCC+, from B+, and revised its outlook to CreditWatch Negative, from stable. The agency also downgraded the company’s first-lien debt to CCC+, from B+, and its second-lien debt to CCC-, from B-.

Moody’s downgraded First Brands’ corporate family rating by two notches to Caa1, from B2; cut the first-lien debt to Caa1, from B1, and the second-lien debt to Caa3, from Caa1; and revised the outlook to negative, from stable.

Moody’s, in its Sept. 22 ratings report, said that “risks have materialized rapidly following a pause in the company’s efforts last month to refinance its capital structure. We believe that waning investor sentiment reflected in the request for additional transparency and recent distressed trading prices of the company’s debt make a refinancing difficult.” Ultimately, several of the company’s special purpose entities preceded the company into Chapter 11 as concerns grew around the company’s cash position and off-balance sheet financing.

The bankruptcy filing places ninth on the leaderboard of the top 10 largest defaults in the index.

Defaults table 1.png

Also tripping a default via bankruptcy, Anthology (Astra) filed for Chapter 11 after it entered into a restructuring support agreement (RSA) with an ad hoc group of lenders led by Oaktree Capital Management and Nexus Capital Management.

The ad hoc group holds more than 87% of the company’s superpriority first-out term loans and more than 68% of the company’s superpriority second-out term loans.

The provider of cloud-based solutions for higher education, facing lower bookings and elevated customer attrition, previously targeted index loans with an LME transaction in May 2024, exchanging all of its outstanding senior secured first-lien term loan due October 2028, and a portion of its senior secured second-lien term loan due October 2029, at a discount to par, for several tranches of secured debt.

Health check
On the topic of LMEs, Summit Behavioral Healthcare was hit with a downgrade to Selective Default on Sept. 2 after first-lien term loan holders swapped their $790 million of debt par-for-par into a new super-senior second-out term loan due December 2029, and holders of the $177 million revolver due November 2026 exchanged into a super senior first-out revolver due October 2029. Per S&P, the company, which focuses on the substance-use-disorder and acute-psychiatric-treatment end markets, faced a challenging referral environment that impaired margins.

Industry malfunction
With LMEs making up the lion’s share of default activity, LCD drilled down to see which sectors are the biggest contributors to these transactions. Over the past twelve months, Software dominates with issuers from this sector making up 19% of all LME transactions. Media follows, at 13%, and Healthcare Providers and Services take third billing, at 10%.

Defaults 5.png

Stress metrics
While First Brands has grabbed the headlines in recent weeks, stress metrics do not point to broad-based systemic risk. Ratings activity over the past three months improved in September, with the ratio of loan facility downgrades to upgrades easing to 1.83x, the best reading for this metric since April 2024.

Defaults 6.png

This three-month rolling calculation remains well below a recent peak of 4.69x in February, which marked the highest level for this metric since July 2020.

Looking at price-based measures, the distress ratio incorporating index loans priced below 80 cents on the dollar also pointed more favorably in September, with the ratio easing to 2.88% by par amount, from 2.92% in August. Note that First Brands’ term loans are not included in these measures since the loans were priced above 90 at the end of August, and were removed from the calculation on account of its default by the end of September.

Defaults 7.png

Featured image by Muhammad Gunawansyah/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.