gettyimages-1695305931.jpg
IPO

Will London’s new trading platform boost liquidity for growth startups?

The London Stock Exchange Group is preparing a new trading venue specifically for shares of private companies.

In an IPO drought that has been particularly acute in the UK, the London Stock Exchange Group is preparing a new trading venue specifically for shares of private companies.

The plan is to provide new liquidity for growing companies and boost the UK’s capital markets. Finance minister Jeremy Hunt has framed it as part of a wider package of measures to encourage not only domestic companies to grow and list in the UK but also to attract global companies.

But can it meet its high ambitions?

Hunt shared official details in a July speech where he set out high-level plans for the UK economy. He confirmed that a new “intermittent trading venue” would be created by the end of 2024 to act as a bridge between the private and public markets.

London exchange officials have since provided additional details, including that it would enable trading of existing shares. This means firms will not use the venue to issue new capital, and it is targeted at professional investors, rather than the public at large. Still, the specifics are subject to consultation and regulatory approval.

 


“We have a very good ecosystem of scale-up businesses in the UK. Businesses that have passed their initial growth stage, have a proven business model and now want to grow further,” said Darko Hajdukovic, head of new primary markets at the exchange. “The problem they face is a lack of access to capital or a high cost of capital, or both. One of the reasons is existing investors do not have clear exit strategies. There are limited options available to them to enable liquidity in their shares.”

He says the new project will enable such companies to access liquidity via public markets infrastructure while remaining private. It also potentially offers the chance for a wider range of investors to access companies.

“For at least the last 10 years, private equity and venture capital have been throwing lots of money at startups, which has meant investors that are more active on the public markets side have been squeezed out,” said Thiha Tun, a partner at Dechert law firm.

A shift in thinking

It will be a similar concept to Nasdaq Private Market, which launched in 2013 with the promise of providing greater liquidity for private companies while also enabling them to maintain a high level of control. Since then, it has facilitated more than $45 billion in transactions. It now offers a range of trading options including tender offers, auctions, block trades and company-directed windows of liquidity.

At the time of launch, LSE’s program is expected to offer monthly set auction windows, and registered companies would have the option of whether to participate.

Hajdukovic is clear that the venue will not be appropriate for all pre-IPO companies. For participation to be worthwhile, a firm needs a reasonably diversified shareholder base.

“Market capitalization is not the right way to think about it, you can have a big company that may have only one or two shareholders,” he said. “This route is probably not going to work for them.”

According to Hajdukovic, this is an evolution in thinking from the UK Treasury’s wholesale markets review, concluded last year, which talked about a new venue for sub-£50 million companies (about $61.1 million).

This shift may be welcomed by some.

Madeleine Ingram, director at Calculus Capital, an investment firm focused on early-stage companies, said most small and medium-sized businesses in the UK have market caps of less than £50 million, so to focus on those with higher market caps would be “targeting larger companies at a later stage as opposed to those in need of capital at the smaller side of the venture capital fundraising cycle.”

“It is important not to forget these smaller, innovative businesses and continue to support the innovators and game-changers who can grow and scale the UK’s businesses of the future,” she said.

Attracting investors

Getting the balance right on disclosure is crucial. Onerous requirements akin to a light IPO would surely dissuade companies, and investors would likely not see the benefit of participating.

Hajdukovic confirms companies would not need to produce a prospectus or anything of similar depth. But the right level of information needed to provide certainty for investors is yet to be decided.

Tun believes it will provide welcome additional transparency for investors, which could access relatively frequent and consistent disclosure from firms that previously would have been largely closed off to them.

Hajdukovic says firms could be required to provide information to eligible investors about three days before any auction in which they intend to participate.

“Investors will get a lot of benefits,” he said. “They get certainty of execution, they get additional information, and they get easier price discovery.”

Unanswered questions

There are many outstanding details yet to be confirmed. Tun raises concerns about the practicalities of a startup’s employees or management being able to sell shares without themselves or the share buyer falling afoul of the tax rules governing employee ownership schemes.

Perhaps a bigger question is whether the new venue will inject some new life into the UK’s equities markets.

According to the EY organization, there were just 23 IPOs across the LSE’s main market and its AIM market for smaller companies in the first three quarters of this year, raising £953 million total. Over the same period, there were 76 IPOs at $10.6 billion total on the Nasdaq and 20 on the NYSE, raising $8.2 billion.

In a particularly bitter blow, UK-based chipmaker Arm recently chose the Nasdaq as its IPO venue, not listing any shares in London.

The LSE’s program has been positioned as part of a wider drive to improve the vitality of the UK’s capital markets, but will it be a tool to generate an IPO pipeline?

Hajdukovic disagrees: “We really want to solve a genuine problem in the market around companies being able to access the capital they need to grow. Companies should be able to do whatever is right for where they are in their growth lifecycle.”

Although, he said, he does hope they will eventually go public.

Featured image by Dan Kitwood/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.