Last week Marsh, the world’s largest outsourced chief investment officer (OCIO) provider, agreed to acquire Wilshire. The deal is another sign of rising consolidation and represents a significant change of control in an industry where questions of succession abound.
Wilshire advises and builds portfolios for some of the largest asset owners in the country, including the California Public Employees’ Retirement System and the Ohio Police and Fire Pension Fund.
With the acquisition of the California-based investment consultant and OCIO, Marsh adds $221 billion of assets under management and $1.6 trillion of assets under advisement.
Formerly known by the names of its separate units, including Mercer and Marsh McLennan, the fast-growing conglomerate of investment advisory and OCIO businesses has been slowly collapsing these identities into a single brand since January this year.
The deal is expected to close in the first quarter of 2027. Financial terms were not disclosed.
The combination of Marsh and Wilshire is part of a broader trend among OCIOs that began in mid-2018, driven by aging founders, ownership issues and a growing industry.
Dennis Tito founded Wilshire in 1972, in Santa Monica, as an index and risk analytics provider. It later became part of a wave of OCIOs to emerge in the decade following the passage of the 1974 Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), which established stricter fiduciary standards for pension plans and allowed sponsors to delegate investment authority to third-party managers.
CC Capital and Motive Partners bought Wilshire in 2021, with then 80-year-old Tito stepping down as part of the transaction. The two PE firms agreed to exit to Marsh, according to a public statement.
Today, many of the firms that emerged during the same period remain independently owned, including Commonfund and Cambridge Associates. Like Wilshire’s, succession planning at independent firms makes them ripe targets for buyouts and strategic acquisitions.
Marsh has been the most active strategic acquirer. Since 2024, the firm has acquired several businesses, including Vanguard’s OCIO business, and institutional asset managers and advisers Cardano, SECOR Asset Management and AltamarCAM.
Consolidation is creating a barbell effect in the industry, where clients, depending on their size and risk appetite, prefer either mega-providers or small, highly specialized boutique OCIOs, said Charles Skorina, head of an executive search firm that takes his name.
Today, the largest 16 firms manage about 76% of OCIO client assets as of October, mostly pension assets, he said, citing internal data.
Even before the Wilshire deal, Marsh was the biggest manager on the list. Its $850 billion in AUM places it ahead of the OCIO businesses of Goldman Sachs and BlackRock.
For LPs, a steady stream of ownership changes raises questions about changing fees and contractual terms with the firms managing their portfolios. The identity of Wilshire’s acquirer may give LPs peace of mind, said Anna Dunn Tabke, president of Leita Advisory, which advises institutional investors on OCIO and investment consultant searches.
“Clients know that when you get bought by private equity, you get sold by private equity, but Wilshire getting bought by somebody like Marsh means they’re done. A lot of Wilshire clients are probably relieved,” she said.
When an allocator’s OCIO comes under new ownership, clients likely won’t feel the effects of the changes in their contractual agreements for a year or two, Tabke said.
In fact, OCIOs that come under new ownership are unlikely to charge clients higher management fees in order to avoid turnover, at least at first, she said.
“Think about if you like the type of allocations they’re sending you, the service, the research, the back-office operations... And then a year from now, when Marsh and Wilshire have figured out the combination, sit down and ask whether the things you liked are still in place,” Tabke said.
Latest Research
Aerospace & Defense Report: Defense on the Rise
Recent News
Q&A: Bullhound’s Alon Kuperman on Revolut’s path to $1T
Former Carlyle Asia and Warburg Pincus execs launch pan-Asian secondaries fund
Learn about our editorial standards.