For the last decade, the buyout industry has predominately relied on multiple arbitrage and financial engineering to drive portfolio company value growth, paying little heed to operational improvements.
The era, however, concluded with the onset of high interest rates. Increased financing costs and depressed valuations limited GPs’ ability to derive value and fuel growth through leveraged acquisitions or simply riding an industry tailwind.
Consequently, the notion of margin expansion—improving a portfolio company’s profitability by optimizing operations—has gained momentum. The ability to drive value growth by making portcos more profitable has been at the forefront of discussions about what will drive the next stage of PE strategy.
Recent data shows a correlation between the size of PE deals and how much value appreciation was attributable to the profit growth achieved by portfolio companies.
Bucketing North American PE deals by size reveals that medium-sized transactions, rather than large-cap deals, depend more heavily on profit growth to generate value, according to a DealEdge analysis of buyouts and growth equity investments realized between 2010 and 2024.
Deals with equity checks between $150 million and $500 million saw 4.04% value realization stem from profit margin improvement, while those with greater equity sizes experienced margin erosion, the analysis shows.
Industry advisers also said mid-market companies, often with less mature corporate structures, need more operational enhancements than their larger peers.
These smaller businesses often face a transition from “driving growth at all costs” to a focus on operational efficiency and profitability. PE firms usually can step in to implement more sophisticated operating models, said Kevin Desai, a PwC adviser on PE deals.
One approach, for instance, is to bring in experienced corporate executives from large multinationals—think divisional controllers or CFOs—to replace the existing management team, he said.
The value creation story for mature, large businesses is different. Their focus is growth instead of boosting EBITDA margins, plowing their cash flow back into product innovation or sales growth.
“It is fundamentally harder and more expensive to create value in a very large take-private deal than a founder-owned business,” Desai said.
Some, though, would challenge that notion.
Larger corporates could also be inefficient and have legacy structures poised for transformation, said Romain Bégramian, a managing partner at GP-Score, a Paris-based firm that scores and advises PE funds on operational value creation.
In Europe, larger deals are more likely to derive value from margin improvements, said Russel Jones, head of product at DealEdge.
Acquisitions in the region with equity investments between $500 million and $1 billion saw margin expansion contribute roughly 10% to overall value creation — a contrast to smaller deals, which showed negligible margin gains, DealEdge data shows.
Featured image by Pavel Muravev/Getty Images
Learn about our editorial standards.