Tufin Software Technologies, an Israel-based cybersecurity company founded in 2005, went public in 2019 on the New York Stock Exchange. After rising for three months following the public offering, Tufin’s shares declined slowly for another year and a half.
In February 2021, the company announced it would shift to a subscription-based model to boost recurring revenue, following the launch of its cloud services. In the days after the announcement, Tufin’s stock price fell further, likely because, as one critic argued, the company “did a poor job” of explaining the impact of the “surprise” change in business model. Its stock then traded mostly flat for the next year, even as revenue started to improve.
Then, in August, roughly three years after its IPO, tech-focused private equity shop Turn/River Capital acquired Tufin for roughly $570 million.
The acquisition is a fresh example of a private equity firm taking advantage of this year’s tech valuation declines to scoop up companies at deep discounts. For Tufin, the move made sense, allowing it to focus on its business model transition away from the short-term demands of public shareholders.
“Even though it was the right long-term decision for them [Tufin] to make, that’s not something public shareholders have the patience for, and they moved on from the stock,” said Dominic Ang, founding partner at Turn/River. “It’s something that’s undervalued by public shareholders: long-term value creation.”
Going private will give Tufin more time to manage its transition, Ang said, adding that the move is reasonable because SaaS products have become the majority of the company’s sales. The change yielded promising early results. In fiscal 2021, Tufin’s revenue rose 10%, reversing a decline in 2020.
However, the company’s growth is expected to slow for two to three years before returning to its previous trajectory. Turn/River will help Tufin to speed the transition and accelerate its growth potentially beyond its previous levels, Ang said.
There have been at least five technology company take-privates this year in the $300 million to $2 billion deal size range, according to PitchBook data. That includes Thoma Bravo‘s takeover of Mercell and GI Partners’ acquisition of GTY Technology.
Tufin’s case is an example of legacy tech companies trying to manage a challenging transition that is increasingly seen among software makers, said Brendan Burke, a senior emerging technology analyst at PitchBook. Other prominent examples include data analytics company Splunk and cloud-computing giant Citrix Systems, which also have pursued the transition from on-premise licensing to a cloud-based SaaS model, which is favored by investors for its consistent revenue generation.
However, the process can be costly, face execution risk and create customer retention challenges. In addition, changes to accounting rules sometimes result in later revenue recognition.
Splunk, for instance, has struggled with the transition for several years. The company recorded its first-ever annual revenue decline for the fiscal year ended in January 2021 before seeing its revenue climb up again. The stock price has been choppy, performing reasonably well between 2018 and late 2020 before weakening and eventually getting caught in the market downturn this year.
Splunk’s challenges illustrate the difficulties public companies face making this kind of transition, Burke said.
“A lot of these legacy software companies have to manage presenting that to investors and attempt to maintain their share price or consider going private based on how that communication goes,” Burke said.
Managing communication with shareholders can be even more difficult for small-cap companies, especially in a volatile market, Burke added. These companies are in weaker liquidity positions, and public investors are less likely to support them during challenging times.
The recent downturn in software valuations not only offered private equity firms a chance to scoop up cheap companies, but also made companies rethink how to generate more sustainable growth and undertake transitions that are very difficult to make in the public markets, Ang said.
Companies often consider significant transitions with private capital partners, who can provide the patient capital and operational expertise to accelerate and optimize the process, Ang added.
Featured image by Jirsak/Shutterstock
Learn about our editorial standards.