Deal-hungry private credit managers have shown a rising appetite for offering preferred equity investments in young energy companies as they are eager to put capital to work.
Large private credit managers have stepped up as active providers of this quasi-equity financing in recent quarters, according to market sources, backing deals worth several hundred million dollars each—a sharp increase from the typical sub-$100 million transactions of the past. These deals typically feature more stringent protections that mirror the terms seen in loan agreements.
The recent uptick in debt-like preferred equity deals signals a willingness by private credit funds to stretch their risk tolerance amid pressure to strike new pacts.
“They are chomping at the bit to do these deals in any way they can,” said Angela Hagerman, a debt finance partner at Reed Smith in the energy sector. “They are not going to do a bad deal, but they will take a look at just about anything.”
Competitive pricing
Some managers, eager to deploy dry powder before their investment windows close, are willing to agree to generous terms on preferred equity deals.
As a result, some companies without solid credit histories have been able to secure more attractive pricing from these transactions than they might through private credit deals. For example, a young upstream producer raised preferred equity at a dividend north of 10%, which is considered a favorable rate given its lack of a credit record, according to a source close to the transaction.
Overall, the target return for preferred equity deals in the energy market typically ranges between 8% and 13%, according to Izzet Bensusan, CEO and founder of Captona, which owns, operates and co-develops energy infrastructure assets.
This type of financing has now become a popular alternative to debt, particularly for young, marginally profitable energy companies that have been shut out of the conventional lending market.
It has been used increasingly across the energy sector, from upstream producers to oilfield services providers. It has also been more widely used by renewable energy companies to replace or supplement more cumbersome project financing structures like tax equity financing.
Debt-like protections
Many of these deals are structured with more protective provisions than standard equity deals, which would give preferred equity holders an extensive reach over a company’s operations.
These investors may obtain rights to board seats, blocking rights over changes to board composition and business plans and liquidation preferences that ensure their minimum return thresholds are satisfied before any payouts flow to common shareholders.
They can also get special voting rights on compensation plans, as well as provisions controlling the use of proceeds and mandatory sale clauses triggered by default.
“It has a lot of the same technology that you see in a debt instrument in terms of what the borrower or the issuer can and cannot do,” Hagerman said.
While large, established companies may push back on such restrictive terms, younger companies with less leverage are more receptive.
Despite these protections, preferred equity holders still bear more risk than creditors, as their claims are subordinate to secured and unsecured debt in the capital structure, increasing the likelihood of loss in the event of insolvency or bankruptcy.
“Preferred equity investors often ask for preferred dividend payouts and first cash distributions, but they cannot eliminate all the downside risk at once,” said Steve Binz, a managing director in KPMG’s deal advisory group, focusing on the energy and natural resources industry.
“Getting into where you have that guaranteed zero risk of downside like PIK can potentially trip you into debt treatment as opposed to preferred equity in accounting treatment depending on various factors,” he said. “It’s a tricky line for the companies to walk.”
Featured image by Mara Potter/PitchBook News
Learn about our editorial standards.