Dartmouth Hall at Dartmouth College

Lee Snider/Getty Images

Private Credit

Private credit may curb supply shocks, boost stability, according to academic study

Corporate borrowers often switch to direct lending financing when public markets tighten, allowing borrowers to maintain access to capital during periods of stress.

Direct lending is countercyclical to issuance in public corporate credit markets, suggesting that the private credit market could dampen the transmission of credit supply shocks to the real economy, rather than amplify them, according to research from the Tuck School of Business at Dartmouth and the Frankfurt School of Finance & Management.

The thesis counters some of the fears that private credit — less regulated and less familiar to investors and regulators than older segments of the leveraged lending universe — could be increasing systemic financial risk as it has skyrocketed in size in recent years.

“The availability of both BSL and high-yield markets alongside private credit markets makes corporate credit supply more stable,” said author Franz Hinzen, professor at the Tuck School of Business at Dartmouth, in an interview with PitchBook LCD.

“Even when borrowers face constraints on one lender group, the availability of alternatives makes it more likely that a borrower can roll over their debt, repaying existing lenders and making all parties better off.”

The paper, published on April 8, shows that corporate borrowers (and particularly those backed by private equity sponsors) often switch to direct lending financing options when public credit markets tighten, allowing borrowers to maintain access to capital during periods of stress.

The authors note that some recent academic work has cast nonbanks as destabilizing lenders in credit markets, with one paper showing that broadly syndicated loans are three times as cyclical as loans supplied by banks, making broadly syndicated loans a more constrained funding source during periods of volatility.

The research supports the claim that direct lenders have made often: that private credit markets remain open even while public debt markets are shut — a phenomenon observed during several periods of market disruption over the past several years.

“For years, people have framed private credit and BSL markets as in conflict with one another, but our view as a practitioner in both markets was always that there’s room for both, and when the BSL markets shut down we often see issuers turn to private credit for refinancings,” said Lionel Jolivot, partner at J.F. Lehman & Co., an alternative asset manager.

He highlighted the market volatility surrounding US tariff policy in April of 2025 as a recent example of this backstop dynamic, where private credit lenders picked up the slack after banks largely pulled back from lending amid the disruption.

He noted that banks, worried about hung debt on deals they committed to shortly before that disruption, also sold off some of that paper to private credit firms while CLOs were unlikely to buy.

Hinzen also said that a major reason that borrowers are able to efficiently arbitrage between the two markets is because they have largely converged in many areas, as the public and private debt instruments become more interchangeable.

The authors reviewed the share of firms that switched from leveraged loans to private credit financing from 2010 to 2024, primarily using data from PitchBook LCD, showing that firms move into private credit when credit availability in the syndicated loan market declines. This was demonstrated across both European and US datasets.

Sign up for The Credit Pitch

Weekly coverage of US and European loans, bonds, private credit, and more.

Private credit could potentially stabilize investment and employment during downturns by helping borrowers bypass a frozen syndicated market during periods of tightened credit conditions, but the authors also note that this comes with a trade-off, as it “simultaneously shifts intermediation into a less transparent and less regulated domain.”

The paper noted that banks and private credit funds are increasingly interconnected, and that future research could investigate potential contagion channels arising from the specific liability structures of direct lending funds.

While the conclusions of this research suggest that private credit can bolster systemic financial stability, regulators are still increasing their investigations into the asset class after the wave of redemption headlines this year.

The SEC has launched several enforcement investigations of private credit firms in recent months, looking into how managers value their loans and whether the way these loans are packaged for different investors creates conflicts of interest, the Wall Street Journal reported on April 22.

Additionally, the Treasury Department has begun requesting additional information from private fund managers and insurance firms, and the Federal Reserve is also asking banks about their private credit exposures, the report said.

Lee Snider/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.