Middle Market_header.png

Jenna O’Malley/PitchBook News

People

Private credit pros will take a compensation hit this year

Weaker performance and fundraising means there’s less to go around, says compensation consultant Johnson Associates.
Middle Market_header.png

Jenna O’Malley/PitchBook News

Private credit bonuses are going to take a hit this year.

That’s according to compensation consulting firm Johnson Associates, which projects that incentive compensation for private credit professionals will end the year anywhere from 2.5% to 7.5% down from last year.

That’s a steep decline from the firm’s projected incentive funding for private credit at the end of 2025: Johnson Associates expected incentives to increase from 5% to 10% for 2026.

Related read: Can private market talent evolve? The industry isn’t so sure.

The less-than-stellar expectations for private credit professionals are the product of muted returns and fundraising declines, said Alan Johnson, managing director and founder of Johnson Associates.

Through the first half of 2025, the rolling one-year internal rate of return for private credit funds fell to 3.9%, according to PitchBook’s latest Global Private Debt Report. This compares with a 5-year rolling IRR of 9.2% and a 10-year figure of 7.8%.

Private credit funds collected $221 billion in 2025, down roughly 7% from 2024 and the lowest amount raised since 2018. The number of funds to close reached the lowest level on record, 206.

“The economics are shrinking,” Johnson said.

AUM growth, fundraising

This shakeout comes on the back of a period of exponential growth for the asset class, which led asset managers to ramp up hiring for specialized private credit talent.

From 2024 to 2025, for example, financial recruiting firm RCQ Associates observed a 58% increase in the number of hiring mandates for asset-backed finance investment staff positions. RCQ also logged a 26% annual increase in private credit and CLO managers’ demand for sell-side structuring professionals.

In a related 2025 RCQ survey of private credit industry professionals, over half of respondents said they expected their team to grow over the next 12 months.

Now, these hires could be subject to layoffs, pay cuts and being pushed out of firms that did overzealous hiring during a boom period, Johnson said. At the very least, he expects private credit firms to pull back on competitive offers and massive pay packages.

“We had a gold rush year, and average people were able to move anywhere and were being paid a lot,” he said. “The script will follow what’s happening in private equity. After years of so-so returns, firms are recognizing their top performers and not as desperate to keep other people as they once were.”

If the current market negatively impacts bonuses, it would be a particular blow to investment staff in the highest-ranking positions.

Managing directors at private credit firms can collect bonuses that are anywhere from 100% to 300% of their base salaries, which can be upward of $400,000, according to finance recruiting firm Selby Jennings.

Principals, who are one step down from managing directors, can collect incentives that even out to double their base compensation, and vice presidents typically make anywhere from 100% to 150% of their base.

Still, Johnson said talent shouldn’t make any decisions based on this year’s pay. Instead, they should consider their firm’s edge in an increasingly competitive market.

“If you feel your firm is reasonably competitive and your pay goes down some, that’s the business. I wouldn’t obsess about that. If I’m going to obsess about anything, it would be my career opportunities. Do I feel good about how my firm views performance and what the future might be?”

Learn about our editorial standards.