Dollar sign is written on a cloudy glass facing a commercial and business district. Illustration of the concept of commercial competition, financial world and money

Featured image by Dragon Claws/Getty Images

Private Credit

Discounts fade for private credit secondaries as market grows up

The fledgling private credit secondaries market is experiencing a growth spurt at the same time that pricing is meaningfully tightening in the adolescent asset class.

The fledgling private credit secondaries market is experiencing a growth spurt as a series of multibillion-dollar continuation vehicles brings the asset class to an unprecedented scale. While the norms and dynamics of the adolescent market are being figured out in real time, demand for assets has chipped away at what is traditionally expected in secondary sales — pricing discounts.

Indeed, sources tell LCD that some continuation vehicles are pricing at par — and some even at a premium to par — at least on a nominal basis.

This may seem counterintuitive. Liquidity offered to LPs via continuation vehicles is generally expected to reflect the addition of a liquidity premium, translating into discounts for secondaries buyers. And this general financial principle still rings true in the credit secondaries space, but in more indirect ways.

The burgeoning secondaries market is giving private credit fund investors a new way to exit their investments, which is an especially important tool for GPs to employ in the face of fundraising fatigue, as credit secondaries allow for the return of capital to LPs who can then use the new investment capacity to make allocations in newer funds.

The exact mechanics of the market, however, including how discounts get priced in, the way sale processes are run, and what the broader norms of the asset class will be, are still in flux and up for debate, as advisors, buyers, and sellers work out conventions of the uncharted space as they go.

“It’s still an emerging market — there have only been about a half-dozen of these $1 billion+ continuation vehicles done in the space, and those have mostly been in the past year or so. We’re in the very early innings,” said Kevan Comstock, managing director at Lazard’s private capital advisory group, in an interview with LCD.

This period of identity-formation is compelled by the pace of growth, as credit secondaries volume is expected to triple from 2023 levels by the end of this year, according to a report by Evercore, and continuation vehicles are only projected to become more commonplace.

“The GP-led continuation vehicle technology [in PE secondaries] has existed for many years, but it is only recently being applied to credit in a meaningful way, accelerating the innovation in the industry,” said Fred Han, partner at Campbell Lutyens, also in an interview with LCD.

Adolescent phases are known to be fleeting, however. The market’s current iteration is still very much subject to change, according to market participants. As one secondaries advisor said: “If we speak about [the credit secondaries market norms] again in six months, the conversation might be completely different.”

Coming of age
While these continuation vehicles have only recently begun transacting at meaningful volumes, all of the nearly dozen buyers and advisors that LCD spoke to confirmed that pricing has tightened significantly over the past 18 months. However, most maintained that the still-niche asset class can be easily misunderstood by primary market GPs and LPs who have no experience doing a private credit secondaries transaction. To be fair, few have this experience at this early stage in the market’s evolution.

Pricing is one of the most easily misconstrued elements of the market, with the headline pricing generally encompassing at least several points of discount above effective pricing. Here’s why: Secondaries accounting means that deals priced at par (or in some cases, above it) on a nominal basis often transact at least a few points below. This is partially because par in this context means par of a portfolio’s fair market value — generally around 96 to 98 for the senior loan portfolios that constitute the majority of deal volume for continuation vehicles. The other major form of implicit discount comes from the treatment of the cash flows (primarily interest income) that are generated between a portfolio’s reference date (the frozen point at which a portfolio is valued) and the transaction’s closing date, which generally accrues to the benefit of the buyer. Sources said that this gap is typically around two quarters, and generally provides about two points of discount per quarter (on a senior loan portfolio yielding around 8% annually), meaning an average deal gets around four points of effective discount from the post-record date cash flows. Advisory sources told us that this is one of the reasons why buyers are incentivized to drag out processes for as long as they can, and that GPs will sometimes cap the amount of cash flows that can accrue to the buyers’ benefit, sometimes limiting it to around six months’ worth of post-reference date cash flows.

This convention, however, like most in credit secondaries, is still evolving as participants work out the kinks of the market.

Discrete discounts
Credit secondaries sources that have participated in or worked on the half-dozen mega-continuation vehicles in the market gave LCD generalized but realistic figures to illustrate how these processes usually work. For example, a deal that prices nominally above par — for example, 102 — may get three points of discount from the portfolio’s NAV (which may be marked at 97) and another four points from the two quarters of post-reference date cash flows that have accrued to the buyers’ benefit. This brings the indirect discount to a total of seven points, and an effective price of 95, on a deal that may have a headline price of 102.

This is why no deals have traded at a “true premium” to par, a number of sources said. One banker estimated that the highest effective price seen in the market so far has been par, at most.

Nonetheless, the slim nature of these discounts (and even their complete absence, in extreme cases) has led secondaries buyers to suggest that the margins for error on buying into portfolios at such prices could make it tough to hit double-digit returns for some secondaries funds. It’s possible, but far from straightforward, market sources said.

“It is confusing to understand how the returns will work on some of the deals that transact with such high pricing,” said one investor at a leading private credit secondaries firm, in an interview with LCD.

“Leverage being added to the system helps, and the math may add up, depending on portfolio yield and duration. But it will be a thin trade,” the secondaries investor source said.

Other secondaries investors had a different perspective regarding the lack of deep discounts, suggesting that they are not to be expected when dealing with high-quality credit portfolios.

“While generating liquidity for illiquid assets typically involves some frictional costs, the discounts relative to private equity are narrow, especially for senior performing loans, as the underlying credit is high quality,” said Luca Salvato, partner in Ares Secondaries Group.

Additionally, regardless of tight pricing levels, others argued that the space is far from any oversupply of capital, as there is still plenty of pent-up demand for continuation vehicles from private credit GPs who have only recently seen the liquidity option as completely viable, now that there are sufficient dedicated buyers in the space.

“A GP 18 months ago may have decided to sit on the sideline with a multi-billion continuation fund because they were concerned about going to market and getting a bad result, or maybe inferior pricing. But the conversation today is a bit different in that the market definitely can absorb that volume,” said Ed Goldstein, partner and CIO of Coller Credit Secondaries.

Gray area
One point of sensitivity involved some of the ways that GPs evaluate bids for credit secondaries continuation vehicles. In competitive processes, prospective buyers will naturally try to bid as high as possible while still hitting target returns.

But buyers have other levers they can pull to position themselves favorably with GPs that go beyond pricing. According to advisory sources, buyers will sometimes offer additional concessions around management fees, recycling provisions, and other commitments such as explicit ‘staples’ into primary market fundraises. This means that the buyer agrees to also commit allocations to a private credit GP’s primary market fundraise.

Several buyers balked at the practice of offering higher management fees to get a bid over the line, however, drawing attention to the potential for conflicts of interest that arise from price-dilutive GP economics and the GP’s fiduciary duty to provide exiting LPs liquidity at the best possible price. Put another way, the highest bidder should not be able to offer the best economics or management fees, since higher fees eat into returns, and should translate into a lower bid price, and vice versa.

“It could be unethical for a selling GP to partner with a buyer offering the GP economics when there are other prospective buyers bidding a higher price,” said one secondaries advisory source.

This dynamic is not always clear-cut, as GPs evaluate bids on a “more holistic” basis and weigh several factors.

Sources said pricing is generally the most important consideration, but that GPs could not overlook the potent benefits of some of the additional economics that bidders provide.

“GPs generally prioritize pricing, followed by GP terms around management fees and carried interest, then benefits to their primary market fundraising, and the general certainty that a deal will close,” said Comstock.

“It is nuanced, and there are lots of considerations and trade-offs.”

Featured image by Dragon Claws/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.