As venture capitalists increasingly focus on their existing portfolio investments, a spotlight has been put on a contract clause that gives early investors the right to participate in future rounds.
Follow-on funding dominates dealmaking, accounting for a record 69% of overall VC deal count so far this year, according to PitchBook data. Investors are turning their attention to their best-performing investments, making pro-rata rights an attractive term.
They have been standard for decades, but they are increasingly becoming non-negotiable amid a more investor-friendly environment. In a Sifted survey of over 400 VC firms in June, 78% of respondents said that they were not flexible on the topic.
But critics such as VSC Ventures general partner Jay Kapoor have argued that pro-rata rights in their current form are outdated in a venture market that prioritizes value-add over check writing and are oftentimes unfair to startups and smaller VCs.
Pro-rata rights exist to benefit investors. The logic is that they reward early backers for putting their faith in young startups by letting them avoid dilution from future share issuances.
For startups, however, it can mean early investors become a burden in a later round.
The downside
If a company is doing well, new investors demanding a minimum amount of ownership could be deterred if all existing investors exercise their pro-rata rights.
Furthermore, as a startup grows, it could need a different sort of investor on its board. For example, a pre-seed firm likely won’t be the best entity to help you when you’re post-Series B and looking to expand. Additional shares could come from founders or early employees, but it seems unfair to take more ownership away from the people actually building the product.
This article appeared as part of The Weekend Pitch newsletter. Subscribe to the newsletter here.
In recent years, adding value has become more important—especially in a downturn. A poll from VC firm Creandum on whether VCs really do add value to their portfolio companies revealed that founders rated the average impact of their VCs at 5.2 out of 10. (The VCs gave themselves a higher score of 7.6.)
It may be unsurprising then that if an investor isn’t helping to add value, founders would be reluctant to see them included in a follow-up round if there are new investors wanting to come in.
It is conceivable that if an investor is already guaranteed participation in a future deal, there is less of an incentive to try and add value. And while most VC firms are motivated to make a positive impact by dint of ownership, the privilege of pro-rata is not limited to those that do put in effort.
And while they are designed to be investor-friendly, they don’t always serve smaller VCs.
Pro-rata rights are of little use if you cannot exercise them. A seed-stage investor may be able to pay $1 million in a seed round, but investment strategy and fund limitations could mean that paying a seven figure sum in a Series B just isn’t realistic.
Additionally, existing backers are sometimes asked—or even pressured—by founders or new investors to give up their pro-rata rights to make space for newcomers. Pro-rata rights are legally binding, but an investor is unlikely to sue their own portfolio company over them.
Potential for modernization
Point Nine managing partner Christoph Janz has made the case for a decay rate to be built into pro-rata rights over the course of multiple VC rounds which could help solve some of the investor issues. A firm could have 100% of their pro-rata rights in the first round post their initial investment—i.e., they can maintain their full stake, with the percentage lowering in each subsequent deal.
This would create more space for new investors further down the line while also keeping existing backers in the pool. They would be diluted, but to a lesser extent than if they weren’t able to invest at all. It would provide smaller VC firms with more flexibility to invest.
Having this decay rate would also help if a startup was unhappy with the performance of an investor with such rights. They would still be allowed to contribute to the next round, but their ownership would be reduced in further financings.
For startups, performance-based pro rata rights might be the way forward. If founders are held accountable by their backers to reach certain milestones or metrics, investors should be held accountable to actually deliver services as well.
Some firms have already taken up this philosophy. Reddit co-founder Alexis Ohanian’s firm Seven Seven Six has started providing monthly accountability reviews to each portfolio founder in order to show exactly what their firm has contributed.
Check-ins, workshops and connection building are all services that are incredibly useful to founders—particularly in an uncertain climate. If investors who say that they will provide these services then don’t, their pro-rata rights should either be reduced or removed entirely.
Pro-rata rights will remain an important part of negotiations for investors, but as VC changes, there is scope for these terms to modernize with the market.
Featured image by Drew Sanders/PitchBook News
Learn about our editorial standards.