Despite steadily increasing EBITDA and revenue among privately held companies, Lincoln International says that leverage continues to increase among the borrower set in its Lincoln Private Market Index (LPMI), which makes it more difficult for sponsors to achieve target returns if they exit investments in the current environment.
Lincoln observed an increase in leverage from the inception of a deal to Q2 2025 of approximately 0.5x for every vintage year since 2019, “the exact opposite of expectations for sponsor-led buyouts,” the report stated, highlighting that EBITDA adjustments constitute about 24% of earnings and that the high degree of these adjustments, coupled with elevated interest expenses, means that free cash flow is not widely available to pay down debt.
On the distressed front, Lincoln says that some cracks are forming in relationships between sponsors and lenders, as more sponsors are unwilling to support their portfolio companies and inject more equity into businesses that are struggling. The firm says that they have observed lenders with $21 billion of pre-takeover principal gaining control of businesses so far in 2025 — more than the amount of pre-takeover principal for such transactions from 2019 to 2024 combined.
Lincoln noted that deals done during 2021 and 2022 continue to represent more than 50% of all the companies that Lincoln evaluates, and that the firm continues to observe higher covenant defaults, elevated PIK levels and more instances of lenders taking over businesses from sponsors. Size-weighted covenant defaults increased to 3.4% in Q2, up from 2.9% in the prior quarter, “though a higher default rate may be disguised by significant amendment activity to avoid potential defaults,” the report notes.
PIK interest is present in 11% of all deals Lincoln values, and of those deals, 53% had “bad” PIK (defined as PIK that was not elected or available at deal close but is now being utilized.) This translates to what the firm calls a “shadow default rate” of 6%, compared to 2% back in 2021. Further evidence of mounting distress is found in the average loan-to-value for companies with bad PIK, which was 45% at inception compared to an average of 83% today, the report says.
Recent research from LCD showed that PIK interest among the top 15 BDCs surpassed $1 billon in Q1, reflecting a 20% increase for the 12 months to March 31.
Tale of two markets
Enterprise valuation multiples for new buyouts decreased to 11.9x EBITDA in Q2 on a rolling 18-month basis, compared to their peak 2021 levels of 12.6x, according to the report, which noted that this decrease is despite recent deals for the highest quality assets closing at premium transaction multiples of as high as nearly 25x.
The discrepancy between these outlier premium multiples and the decrease in the overall evaluation multiple figures suggests that the deals that are getting done are for the highest quality companies, and are not representative of the broader private market, according to Lincoln. Most of these premium transaction multiples were in business services and technology companies.
“Private markets are evolving in interesting ways — EBITDA continues to grow, driven by the hottest sectors, but whether these companies are creating equity value for investors remains the big question,” noted Ron Kahn, managing director and co-head of Lincoln’s Valuations and Opinions Group.
The LPMI, which tracks the enterprise value of privately held companies in the US, increased by 2.5% during Q2, driven by steady growth in EBITDA while enterprise value multiples have remained roughly steady since Q1.
Lincoln’s Senior Debt Index (LSDI), which uses much of the same data as the LPMI, registered a quarterly return of 2.3% in Q2, continuing to approximate the lowest return since Q4 2022. The index’s yield also continued to decrease to 10.1% in Q2, down from 10.5% in Q1, as competition drives spreads lower. The report also noted that original issue discounts remained historically tight around 1-1.5%, with some deals lacking OIDs entirely as competition drives lenders to concede the discount.
Featured Image: NicoElNino/Getty Images/iStockphoto
Learn about our editorial standards.