Chess board game. Strategy ideas concept business futuristic graphic icon.

Featured image: Viesturs Davidcuks/Getty Images/iStockphoto

Private Credit

Rocky market tests private credit as lenders reach for market share

Extreme market swings may push borrowers away from the public debt markets and toward private credit, ultimately helping private credit lenders win deals, market participants say.

Global market volatility is scaring away the M&A and buyout activity that the private credit market badly craves. However, the same extreme market swings may also push borrowers away from the public debt markets and toward private credit, ultimately helping private credit lenders win deals, market participants say.

Private credit can gain market share during periods of market dislocation since transactions are not subject to the risk involved during a syndication process. Last week, primary issuance in the syndicated loan market froze and turned would-be borrowers away, similar to what happened as the Covid pandemic unfolded in March 2020.

“Companies need capital, and they can’t access the public markets. One of the best attributes of a private solution is that you don’t have to wonder about where a deal is going to price. People are saying they’re willing to pay for the insurance that private credit can offer,” said Jim Miller, co-head of direct lending at Ares Management.

“The amount of activity today, the deal quality, and improvement in loan terms is meaningfully better than three weeks ago. We expect to take more market share on what may be a smaller number of deals.”

Vivek Mathew, president of Antares Capital Advisers, said the current market volatility was leading advisers to take stock of options.

“We may see more pivoting to private financings in a volatile environment. We haven’t seen widespread retraction from the BSL market, but naturally the question is being asked: Am I better off with a private execution versus a syndicated one? Private can be a source of certainty in the midst of uncertainty because you can transact quickly.”

Loans available — at a price
In recent weeks, spreads on private credit loans have increased, and fees have risen, roughly tracking the move of debt prices in the syndicated loan market.

A private credit loan today might price around S+525-575, around 100-150 bps wider than two weeks ago, while fees have increased by roughly one point, market participants say.

More deals in the syndicated loan market have been “flexed” higher in recent weeks, a sign of volatile market conditions. In the last 30 days, arrangers sweetened the terms on nine BSL transactions in favor of lenders, versus 11 deals where spreads were cut. This is a significant shift from recent months when most changes went in one direction — in favor of borrowers.

In contrast, private credit borrowers are immune to “flex.” These loans close at an agreed-upon spread and terms, and are less prone to market gyrations.

During the first quarter, the private credit market battled with the syndicated loan market for transactions. Many private credit borrowers obtained cheaper debt in the syndicated market.

PC Selloff 1.png

But since the volatility began, this competitive dynamic has lessened, helping the private credit market make some gains, according to market participants.

After a fallow quarter for M&A and LBOs — a reality that affects both markets — at least two loans have embraced private credit financing in recent weeks, or appear to be moving in that direction: CEC Entertainment, which operates and franchises Chuck E. Cheese and Peter Piper Pizza, to refinance 6.75% notes due May 2026, and Lakeview Farms’ $500 million private loan to buy yogurt maker noosa Holdings and refinance debt.

Both companies face challenges that could make private debt a more attractive option, such as avoiding the scrutiny of ratings agencies. So while recent market volatility is a factor, it isn’t the only driver. In fact, as early as February — before the market turmoil — there was already talk that Lakeview Farms was turning to private credit.

Harder hit for big deals?
Some say that transactions involving larger borrowers, such as companies generating around $100 million in EBITDA or more, are most vulnerable to the uncertainty prompted by the global markets sell-off. It could result in an uneven impact across the market.

Michael Ewald, global head of Bain Capital’s Private Credit Group, noted that middle market deals had seen less of a jump in pricing than in the upper end of the market.

“There is a countervailing dynamic in the middle market so far where we should also see an increase in spreads, because risk has gone up. But there are so few deals to be done and there is a fair amount of private credit dry powder. So, there’s this weird competitive dynamic that is almost preventing the appropriate risk-adjusted return from showing itself,” said Ewald.

“We are still seeing the odd deal get done. But term sheets are going back with bracketed pricing and a wider range, with expectations set that actual pricing would likely be on the higher end of that range,” he noted.

Larger deals, which have the option of obtaining financing in either the syndicated market or from private credit lenders, may be most affected by the changing regulation, according to some.

“Upper middle market borrowers typically have diversified, international revenue and operations which may make navigating tariffs more challenging,” Morningstar DBRS said in an April 3 report. Morningstar DBRS defines upper middle market companies as those with greater than $150 million of EBITDA.

President Donald Trump’s second presidential win raised hopes that dealmaking would increase due to accommodative regulatory policy, but those hopes failed to materialize in the first quarter. The current market sell-off is not offering any relief.

PC Selloff 2.png

“Large and sponsor-based transactions require just that: transactions. Volatility and shifting macro dynamics will almost certainly chill deal activity, providing fewer opportunities for large cap private credit,” said BC Partners in a quarterly newsletter published this week.

With the private credit market continuing to evolve, potentially becoming more like the syndicated market, much attention is on how the two markets react under extreme circumstances.

“Certain parts of the private market and the liquid credit market have been converging for a number of quarters. The volatility will shine a spotlight on the similarities and differences between them,” said Matt Freund, president of Barings BDC.

“This is a vindication of what people have been talking about for a long time about the flexibility between the two markets,” said Freund.

Much will be determined by how long the tariffs last.

“We anticipated new M&A volume in 2025 to rebound sharply with potential to approach 2021 levels, which was a robust time for new deal activity,” said Antares’ Mathew. “Currently, new M&A markets have effectively ground to a halt.”

“The self-inflicted nature of this also means that it can potentially be resolved relatively quickly. The duration and severity of this will ultimately determine outcomes,” Mathew said.

The market also has to consider the downstream implications of tariffs on interest rate policy, as the Federal Reserve weighs the potential for greater inflation and unemployment in the US.

“Rates could stay a little more elevated, and what does that mean to consumer and business spending more broadly?” asks Ewald. “That uncertainty is wreaking havoc with sponsors’ deal models and leaving them asking, ‘How do we actually put a credible bid out there?’”

The wild market swings have turned some investors’ focus toward the potential for a recession and slowing growth.

“When it comes to private credit, volatility is often associated with opportunity and outsized growth,” said Marc Pinto, global head of private credit at Moody’s, adding that he expects private credit will continue to take market share.

“That being said, should current tariffs remain, credit quality will worsen, and asset growth will moderate ...The strategy of funding long-term leveraged assets with long-term capital has worked well in the recent past, but under a severe stress scenario, that model will be tested,” he added.

See also:
Leveraged loan prices plummet following ‘Liberation Day’ tariffs
Tariffs rise to top of due diligence checklist in private credit
Private credit automotive borrowers on collision course with tariffs
DOGE takes on private credit darlings: business services, enterprise software sectors

Featured image: Viesturs Davidcuks/Getty Images/iStockphoto

Learn about our editorial standards.