Berlin, Brandenburg Gate at Sunset

Featured image by Sylvain Sonnet/Getty Images

Private Credit

Software loans are talk of the town as private credit players meet in Berlin

Under watch are buyouts of software businesses that closed in 2021-22. So far, losses and defaults have not accelerated meaningfully, but many at the SuperReturn International conference expect they will.

Loans to software companies remain the sixty-four-million-dollar question for private credit lenders at the SuperReturn International conference this week as tech shares resume their sell-off.

One major investor in enterprise software, Vista Credit Partners, said the firm now considers that about 20% of software businesses overall are in a category described as “failure to thrive.”

These businesses will need to “reestablish their right to exist” given advances in AI, according to Alex Hughes, co-portfolio manager of the firm’s Flagship Credit fund, speaking at the global conference where private debt and equity market professionals convene annually alongside investors.

According to Hughes, the weakest of three categories of software borrowers does not include companies that are AI-agentic, such as Databricks. The company is a developer of an analytics platform for data and artificial intelligence clients. In January 2025, Databricks obtained more than $5 billion in financing, including a $2.25 billion recurring-revenue term loan. JPMorgan was the left lead arranger.

According to Hughes, the largest category of software borrowers is companies that are going to use AI tools to expand margins.

Generally speaking, investors had bought software indiscriminately as a single category, not discerning among these categories.

“Software is not created equally,” said Hughes, speaking on a panel entitled “Private credit: A new continuum — Meeting the challenges of an altered investing era.”

But it’s not only about AI.

Rushin Shah, who is managing director, credit at Veritas Capital, said AI is not the only factor impacting software. So far, the performance of these businesses has not reflected the souring investor sentiment for the sector.

“R&D money got diverted to pay interest,” Shah said. “These businesses remain cash-flow strong.”

On watch
Under watch are buyouts of software businesses that closed in 2021-22, according to market participants. So far, losses and defaults have not accelerated meaningfully, but many expect they will.

“There are going to be losses in software,” said Ted Koenig, founder and CEO of Monroe Capital. He acknowledged that people don’t know what these businesses will look like in one year, and agentic AI is changing all aspects of business services.

Valuations have declined since asset prices hit peak levels in the low-interest-rate environment resulting from the Covid-19 pandemic. This has raised concerns about refinancings of software loans in private credit portfolios, as well as about sharp increases in current loan-to-value ratios (LTVs) versus the levels when loans were issued.

Jeff Levin, head of credit at software-focused PE firm Thoma Bravo, said the current market conditions had opened the door to secondary trading of portions of debt at levels below those where BDCs were marking them in investment portfolios. Some of the activity was driven by the need to fulfill fund redemptions.

“Motivated selling is not that prominent, but it’s starting to happen,” Levin said on a panel at SuperReturn International.

The reckoning for this vintage of software buyouts was still ahead.

“We’ve gone from the golden age of private credit to the age of dispersion,” said David Manlowe, CEO of Benefit Street Partners. This was based on software exposure, he said.

“You’re going to see the full tool kit brought to bear,” Manlowe said, such as through amend-and-extend transactions. He added that he expects the “rubber to meet the road in Q1 2027 as managers work through their exposure to software.”

No experts?
Another problem is that some lenders accumulated significant software exposure without developing a real framework for evaluating it. When sentiment for the sector turned, that gap became impossible to ignore, according to conference attendees.

Lenders found themselves holding meaningful positions in businesses they couldn’t properly assess, with no methodology for distinguishing a fundamentally strong software company from one that simply carried the label. Some responded by abandoning software entirely, a form of poor risk management.

Many remain skeptical about extreme outcomes triggered by AI.

“The idea that enterprises will rapidly swap out their core systems — ERP, payroll, production scheduling, invoicing — for AI-native tools that didn’t exist a year ago, that ignores basic institutional reality. IT departments won’t allow it,” one fund manager said.

The security risks, integration complexity, and operational exposure make it a non-starter, regardless of the potential cost savings. “No rational business bets its day-to-day operations on unproven infrastructure.”

Sign up for The Credit Pitch

Weekly coverage of US and European loans, bonds, private credit, and more.

“The real question is about margins, not extinction,” he said. “AI is already reducing the cost of software development meaningfully — vendors can build features faster and expand into adjacent areas more cheaply. But whether those efficiency gains flow to vendors as higher margins, or get competed away through lower prices, will depend on the dynamics of each specific market. That is the scenario lenders should be stress-testing, not whether their portfolio companies will simply cease to exist.”

Already, evidence abounds of ways AI is increasing efficiency, such as processing documentation, drafting first-pass deal screens, and freeing junior staff from data collection, according to market participants.

In Europe, the opportunity lies less in software itself and more in the services layer — the implementation, customization, and technical consulting needed to actually embed AI into existing business operations, according to market participants.

Given Europe’s SME-heavy economy and the inherently local nature of that work, it is a space the continent is reasonably well placed to capture, market participants say.

Featured image by Sylvain Sonnet/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.