VCs and their attorneys are decrying a first-of-its-kind California law requiring firms to disclose the demographics of founders of startups in their portfolios.
The California Fair Investment Practices by Venture Capital Companies Act, which was passed in October 2023 and amended the following year, is taking effect amid a largely cooled enthusiasm for increasing diversity in Silicon Valley.
The law set a registration deadline of March 1, with a more detailed reporting cutoff coming April 1. California lawmakers are positioning the law as driving “transparency for greater equity and economic empowerment in venture capital investment.”
Attorneys for firms investing in California-based founders say implementation of the act has been rushed, leaving VCs with little time to understand what’s required and obtain the requisite demographic information from their portfolio companies. It’s overseen by the California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation.
The department released the required survey form for collecting demographic data just last month. Founders can opt in or out of the voluntary data collection, which includes race and ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, disability status, veteran status and California residency.
Industry advocates, including the NVCA are urging the department to delay implementation of the law, claiming the process is likely to yield misleading data. The disclosures appear to apply to all 2025 investments made by a VC firm with a “nexus to California.” Attorneys say the language is overly broad. It’s unclear, for instance, whether a California-based firm would have to survey its portfolio companies based outside of the state.
“The current administrative timeline will force investors to rush founders—who are busy building their companies—to fill out sensitive demographic forms,” said Bobby Franklin, NVCA president and CEO, in a letter to California Gov. Gavin Newsom and the financial protection department this month.
The state agency did not respond to a request for comment.
There are also concerns that given the voluntary nature of the data submission, the information that firms ultimately submit could create an inaccurate representation of the diversity of their portfolios. The disclosures will be made public on the regulator’s website.
Firms will have a 60-day notice period to comply with non-reporting. Penalties will be imposed on a per-day basis. Those penalties could range up to $5,000 a day for noncompliance.
The data collection is fairly straightforward for VCs, though time-consuming, said Natasha Dempsey, senior counsel at Foley & Lardner. And the deadlines are coming fast.
“There is a risk of folks not giving it the credence it deserves, and it could take people by surprise when they get hit with some penalties,” she said.
Recent News
Marsh’s Wilshire deal will get aging OCIOs thinking about exits
Q&A: Bullhound’s Alon Kuperman on Revolut’s path to $1T
Learn about our editorial standards.