AI LAW

(Jenna O’Malley/PitchBook News)

Why US Big Law hit the pause button on private equity

Private equity has found a way into US law firms. It has not yet found an easy way through the partners.
AI LAW

(Jenna O’Malley/PitchBook News)

In November last year, McDermott Will & Schulte, a top global law firm, told the Financial Times that it was weighing outside investment as the management services organization (MSO)—a structure by which law firms can raise capital—gained steam. But more than half a year later, it has not reported a deal.

The factors that are keeping it from executing on a deal structure popularized across other industries—and one PE investors are eager to back—are likely the same concerns weighing on many major law firms, according to conversations with legal advisers, bankers and investors in the market.

Most of these MSO deals remain under the radar. Trisha Rich and Josh Porte, partners at Holland & Knight, said their team closed seven MSO deals last year as advisers and 17 or 18 so far this year, with roughly 100 in progress.

“The vast majority are not publicly announced,” Porte said. “It’s really the tip of the iceberg—then everything else is below the waterline.”

In the UK, non-law ownership of firms has been allowed since 2012, but the US has been slow to catch up, PitchBook has reported.

Arizona’s 2021 decision to allow alternative business structures, or ABSs, briefly suggested a wider opening for non-lawyer ownership in the US. When that model failed to spread broadly, investors shifted focus to MSOs.

Bob Maiden, a managing director at Focus Investment Banking, said MSOs are likely to be the structure of choice for outside investment in US law firms, while ABSs remain more limited because they depend on state-level regulations.

MSOs separate a law firm’s business operations from its legal practice, allowing investors to back technology, marketing, intake and other administrative functions while lawyers retain control of legal work.

The question is not whether or not US law-firm MSOs can be done. “The MSO structure is not new,” said Jonathan Kaye, partner and global co-head of business services at Rothschild & Co. “What is new is that this is now being evaluated in the context of law firms, and there are a few that have actually consummated, and there are many more coming.”

The question is which large commercial law partnership will be willing to move first.

“They don’t want to be first, but they want to be second,” said Lucian Pera, a partner at Adams & Reese in Nashville, who advises law firms and investors on ownership and MSO structures.

He said he hears that refrain from large-firm leaders and that the hesitation is less about timidity than arithmetic: The bigger the partnership, the more owners must sign off on a deal that touches their pay, autonomy and culture.

The MSO pitch has to clear two key hurdles: The firm must desire outside capital, and its partners must approve the deal.

And the math is daunting. To stand up an MSO, “you would have to be able to corral hundreds of partners to agree to that”—far harder than at a firm with “a handful of partners” or a single founder nearing retirement, said Gretta Rusanow, managing director and head of advisory services at Citi Wealth’s Law Firm Group, which tracks more than 200 firms.

The largest firms, she added, “have enough capital to absorb these added cost pressures. They don’t need that. They can tap their own annual cash revenue, partner paid-in capital or banks.”

Kirkland & Ellis, the first firm to clear $10 billion in revenue, is funding its own artificial intelligence build rather than reaching for an investor.

So the deals that close tend to concentrate where one or two owners control decision-making, and the business depends more on brand than on any single lawyer.

Examples include Phoenix-based Rafi Law Group, which raised capital from Fortress in April; Dudley DeBosier, in Louisiana, partnered in January with Orion Legal MSO, backed by Uplift Investors; and Massumi + Consoli, a transactional boutique founded by former Kirkland partners, sold a back-office stake to Trive Capital in May. Each was a deal that a handful of people could approve.

In personal injury, the asset is often the marketing machine—the billboard, the call center, the case pipeline. In commercial law, the asset is more often the partner.

What makes Big Law genuinely hard is that talent can walk, taking clients with them.

“Lawyers generally can’t have noncompetes,” said Austin Maloney, a Hunton Andrews Kurth partner specializing in MSO transactions. That makes rollover equity, vesting schedules and deferred payouts [offered by the MSO structure] more important than in ordinary private equity deals.

But Maloney also noted some junior partners and senior associates may push back on an MSO proposal due to concerns around lower compensation, culture change or having to answer to private equity investors.

Regulation adds another reason to wait. Illinois, Colorado and California have advanced measures this year aimed at curbing investor influence over law firms.

Some badly structured deals may draw scrutiny but will not stop the market, said Frederick Shelton, CEO of Shelton & Steele, a firm-side MSO adviser. “If you put a speed bump on the road, that doesn’t stop all the traffic.”

Maiden of Focus puts the untapped US law firm market at $400 billion.

“If you go into any city and think about all the biggest law firms on billboards in that city,” said Lee Minkoff, a managing director at Renovus Capital Partners, “there’s a high likelihood they are either speaking to private equity, or speaking to investment bankers about speaking to private equity.”

For a cautious 200-partner firm, though, a speed bump is reason enough to let someone else go first.

Learn about our editorial standards.