shutterstock-2167292355-ktc.jpg
LPs

LP Spotlight: Sapphire Partners on how emerging VC managers can stand out

An LP discusses the current fundraising environment and what emerging managers can do to differentiate themselves in a crowded market.

2022 is proving to be a record year for venture fundraising. But not all funds are receiving equal treatment from limited partners.

While mega-funds may have raised their largest vehicles ever, the proportion of US VC capital going to emerging managers—that are investing out their first, second or third funds—hit a decade low in Q2, according to the latest NVCA-PitchBook Venture Monitor.

We spoke with Laura Thompson, a partner at Sapphire Partners, an LP arm within Sapphire Ventures, about the current fundraising environment, how emerging managers can grab LPs’ attention and why there is no one-size-fits-all strategy for marking down VC portfolio companies.

Sapphire Partners, which operates out of an evergreen vehicle, invests in early-stage established and emerging venture funds based in the US, Europe and Israel.

This article was edited and condensed for clarity.

PitchBook: Despite the market downturn, 2022 has been a phenomenal year for venture fundraising. Did most of this fundraising start in 2021 or earlier?

Thompson: I think funds with established LP bases don’t usually surprise LPs with fundraising. Yes, many of the fundraising processes started last year, even for the recently closed funds. However, if you look at the numbers, most fundraising was from mega-funds and smaller established funds, which LPs prioritize since they prioritize existing relationships. When the market environment turns, as it has, LPs gravitate toward more established platforms because it gives them comfort. This can be a big challenge for emerging managers, especially those raising first funds.

How can emerging managers stand out in this market? It seems nearly impossible now.

As we go through pitch decks, many funds seem good. That’s why I think there’s nothing as powerful for LPs as references. The strongest references come from founders, GPs and other LPs. For instance, if a founder tells me, “I love this person. Here’s my direct kind of experience working with them,” that’s a powerful reference.

Also, it is such a crowded market now, I feel there has to be something different about a new manager. Different comes in many flavors, and it is very LP-specific. For instance, we have been in Europe for a long time, but I know a bunch of LPs who want to build their European portfolios. I also think climate change is on top of everyone’s minds now, and some LPs feel they don’t have enough exposure to climate-focused funds. Ultimately, as a new manager, you need to show LPs how your fund will be additive to LPs’ portfolios.

What if you are an emerging manager that started fundraising this year? Will these funds be able to close their funds?

If you already know LPs, you’ve probably been having conversations for years and LPs are comfortable with your body of work, you might be fine. Or, if you are raising a smaller fund, that might be fine, too. It is also always easier to start a new fund when you are spinning out of an established fund. But if you are not doing one of those things, I think it will be quite tricky to raise now.

I understand that some traditional LPs, such as endowments, foundations and pension plans, may not have been able to re-up with all existing relationships that were raising funds this year. They were overallocated to venture, especially as the stock market dipped. As a fund-of-funds, you don’t need to manage your VC exposure against other asset classes. How did you deal with many firms coming back to market with larger funds this year?

We most usually prioritize re-ups with our existing relationships. In the past, we’ve invested with at least a couple of new funds a year, and the same is true for this year. But, our bandwidth has been challenged by all the re-ups we have had in the past couple years and we haven’t had much additional room for more new managers, which is a bummer as we have missed out on some good new folks.

Besides climate, are there any sectors or topics you feel don’t have enough attention from venture capitalists now?

When I look at the market, I don’t see many holes. But one of the holes I see is small-sized funds that stay small. These are funds that are under $50 million. If you have a small fund, even if your ownership in each company is tiny, one strong exit can drive outsize returns.

Company valuations are clearly lower this year than they were last year. Are you seeing GPs mark down their existing investments? Are you expecting to see significant write downs?

Given the market has radically changed, I believe managers should think carefully about their portfolio company valuations. If you are a new firm that only has seed and Series A companies, you could probably be less aggressive with markdowns.

But there’s no one right answer, which makes it tough for everyone, in my opinion. We’ve seen GPs mark down some of their companies by 25% to 50%. These could be companies that are performing really well but received their valuation in a different environment than today. And then there are some companies that have been impacted operationally, which might put them in a little more risk.

Correction: After the article was published, the answers were updated to include more details on Sapphire’s investments in 2022.

Featured image by eamesBot/Shutterstock

Learn about our editorial standards.