Secondaries trophy assets header

Featured image by Jenna O’Malley/PitchBook News

Weekend Analysis

Time for secondaries to take center stage?

Following a surge in interest and funds, the stage is set for secondaries to move into the private markets mainstream.

Secondaries are certainly having a bit of a moment. Secondaries funds raised $78.3 billion last year, according to PitchBook’s 2023 Annual Global Private Market Fundraising Report. That total had been surpassed only once before, in 2020, when they pulled in $84.8 billion.

However, the 2023 tally was spread across just 72 funds—the lowest fund count since 2019—and just four funds accounted for 60.7% of the total. Much like in broader private equity fundraising, the success of several large funds is heavily skewing the numbers.

Secondaries funds also continue to account for only a small share of the overall market—6.7% of private capital raised last year. And, just 3.5% of total private capital assets under management (as of June 30, 2023).

My point here isn’t to pour cold water on the buzz around secondaries, but to emphasize it is still relatively early days for the growth of the strategy. Particularly on the GP-led side, which has been responsible for much of the recent enthusiasm. For the secondaries universe to reach the next stage in its evolution, further specialization is inevitable, as is a better alignment of interests between GPs and LPs.

There does seem to be plenty of potential for secondaries markets to grow considerably. Especially as GPs continue to be under pressure to raise their distributions despite challenging exit conditions.

For instance, Bain’s recently published 2024 Global Private Equity Report suggests that buyout funds are being weighed down by 28,000 unsold companies, worth around $3.2 trillion, 40% of which they have held for four years or longer. In better market conditions they could reasonably have expected to sell or IPO many of these companies by now.

“This backlog is massive by historical standards—four times by value what it was during the global financial crisis,” the report comments.

PE funds’ distribution stats have become some of their most closely-watched metrics of late. According to investment bank Raymond James’ Q1 2024 Fundraising Market Analysis, private equity funds last year returned the lowest amount of cash to investors than in any year since 2009, with distributions as a percentage of NAV at 11.2%. The second lowest on record during the last 25 years.

The market conditions are ripe

It’s clear market conditions have created plenty of pent-up supply and demand for generating liquidity. But do secondaries as a strategy have a long-term future? I think so.

Clearly, there would be less interest in secondaries if M&A and IPO conditions were to materially improve. And there is good reason to hope for a thawing. However, there are several reasons to think the strategy is likely here to stay as a meaningful part of the private capital ecosystem.

Sponsor-to-sponsor deals have long accounted for a significant share of PE exit activity. But GPs are increasingly questioning why they should sell trophy assets to a competitor just to watch them generate returns for someone else.

Putting high-quality assets into a continuation vehicle can be a win-win-win scenario—GPs can hang onto trophy assets for longer, LPs that want to cash out can do so and new investors can gain exposure to those assets at a likely discount. Although these deal mathematics are most applicable in a slow-exit environment, the logic applies more generally.

Much of the stigma around secondaries deals has also gone away. In their early days, driven by LP-led activity, the need for a secondary transaction implied something had gone wrong. But as the private markets have grown and become more complex, and market conditions have shifted, secondaries have become an accepted tool for generating liquidity and managing the needs of different stakeholders.

If we take a really zoomed out view, there are also significant questions about the long-term health of the IPO markets. The success stories of the last couple of weeks don’t represent an instant fix. The long-term trend is that public markets are shrinking, and many question what real benefits a public listing brings anymore. The recent talk of private IPOs (a complete misnomer in my opinion, but that’s for another time…) is another indication of how “exits” that stay within the private markets universe look set to continue to grow in popularity, potentially in place of public markets solutions.

And that is just to cherry pick a few of the factors that will keep secondaries growing. I believe there are others, too.

Time to mature

As with any maturing area of the financial markets there are issues that will need to be resolved to smooth the path to continued growth.

Although several mega-funds now operate in the secondaries universe—for instance, in January, Lexington Partners closed the world’s largest-ever secondaries fund on $22.7 billion—getting large secondaries deals over the line has typically been difficult due to a relative lack of capital and buyers not wanting to be overexposed from a risk perspective.

This may ease as more funds join the fray and funds grow in size. Lately secondaries buyers have been turning to co-investments to boost their war chests. And, interestingly, some traditional buyout funds also appear to be dipping their toes into the market, further expanding the potential capital universe.

For instance, last year Astorg launched its GP Equity Solutions strategy, which will specifically invest in single-asset continuation vehicles, Ardian is reported to be fundraising for a large secondaries fund and there have been media reports that Leonard Green may launch a fund targeting GP-led secondaries later this year. In January, Accel-KKR was the lead investor in a continuation vehicle from LEA Partners.

There also remain fundamental issues around building trust. Structures such as continuation funds have had a bad rap in the past, and resentment and misunderstanding can easily build-up between GPs and LPs if there is bad communication or deals processes are managed poorly, such as LPs feeling election periods are unduly short.

At SuperReturn Secondaries Europe, which took place in London earlier this month, ensuring real alignment between all parties in a secondaries deals came up as a topic of conversation in several panels. Certain speakers stressed the importance of ensuring LP needs are given due consideration, and for buyers of ensuring the GP is genuinely invested in the long-term success of the assets on offer rather than simply trying to cash out and put a positive spin on it

As the industry becomes more complex and specialized so too, will terminology. What is meant by the catch-all term secondaries will need to evolve. Infrastructure, real estate, private credit and venture capital secondaries were all discussed as areas for expansion at SuperReturn Secondaries Europe.

Another important topic for discussion was how the market is becoming increasingly bifurcated between LP-led and GP-led deals, which are fundamentally quite different beasts. Many secondaries funds operate as commingled generalists that will play in both sides of the market. However, some attendees were keen to see more specialization, with funds picking a side.

This market that was once dominated by LP-led activity may become increasingly synonymous with GP-led deals.

Featured image by Jenna O’Malley/PitchBook News

Learn about our editorial standards.