Silicon Valley Night Aerial

Silicon Valley

Gado/Getty Images

Venture Capital

VC firm sues California regulator over portfolio diversity disclosures

The suit is the sharpest pushback yet from investors over founder demographic reporting.
Silicon Valley Night Aerial

Silicon Valley

Gado/Getty Images

Early-stage venture firm 1517 Fund has sued the California regulator that’s overseeing the delayed rollout of a controversial new portfolio diversity disclosure requirement, claiming the law is unconstitutional.

It’s the sharpest pushback yet from VCs, who have called the rules an overreach that burdens investors and the startups they fund. The complaint appears to be the first lawsuit over the California Fair Investment Practices by Venture Capital Companies Act.

The lawsuit was filed Thursday in the US Eastern District of California against Khalil “KC” Mohseni, the commissioner of the California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation.

“The government can’t force you to speak if you don’t want to speak,” said Wilson Freeman, an attorney representing 1517 Fund.

The new law, initially passed in October 2023 and amended in 2024, requires VCs to collect and publicly report demographic information from the founders they back. It applies to VCs based in California and to out-of-state investors backing California startups, with penalties of up to $5,000 per day for noncompliance. Responses are voluntary for founders. The publicly reported data covers race and ethnicity, gender identity, sexual orientation, disability status, veteran status and California residency.

The suit, filed pro bono by the conservative law firm Pacific Legal Foundation, seeks a permanent injunction blocking the law. PLF argues the disclosures violate the First Amendment by compelling investors to speak and the 14th Amendment guarantees of due process and equal protection, along with the Constitution’s commerce clause. It additionally claims the law violates federally protected civil rights.

Investors have criticized the law, in part, arguing that the DFPI lacks authority over venture firms outside California. For instance, 1517 is based in Colorado.

DFPI representatives did not immediately return a request for comment. The regulator has previously said the measure is necessary to “enact transparency for greater equity and economic empowerment in venture capital investment to benefit the public with expanded business opportunity and innovation.”

Following blowback from Silicon Valley, the DFPI indefinitely paused enforcement in March, adding it would begin rulemaking “later this year” to “ensure that the regulations adopted are clear, practical, and effective in achieving the objectives of the law.”

Learn about our editorial standards.