Startups

VCs backed the AI boom. Now founders are burying them in slop.

How founders use AI in emails and pitch decks is the latest screening test for VCs.
11.20.26_Thorne_WEEKEND PITCH2.png

Josie Doan/PitchBook News

Investors spent Thursday celebrating Anthropic’s historic Nasdaq debut, reckoning that the enthusiastic reception validates the pricey marks currently bolstering their portfolios.

But in their own work with founders, AI is getting a chillier welcome.

Anthropic‘s IPO raised $81.3 billion, the largest on record, on a bet that AI will rewrite the rules of how work gets done. For VCs, that brave new world is already landing—and a lot is going straight to the trash.

Lucas Mittelmeier, a VC at Heal Capital, estimates that 40% of the cold inbound outreach he receives from founders is obviously AI-generated. He thinks the actual volume of AI missives could be around 80%, though it’s not always so obvious.

“Very often I immediately trash cold inbound when I feel it’s low-value and not differentiated AI slop,” he said.

You probably already know the telltale signs: sentences overloaded with repetitive words, dull slide layouts, and generative AI’s favorite construction, “It’s not X, it’s Y.”

Sign up for The Daily Pitch newsletter

The rise in the use of AI for fundraising and investor communications puts GPs in an awkward spot. The technology they’ve bet virtually everything on has changed how founders approach them for the worse.

Founders who let chatbots write their core pitches and design their decks are getting tossed, and investors increasingly see the way founders use AI as a stand-in for how they’ll sell and market their product. If AI is deployed poorly in ordinary email, it is an instant red flag.

“Use it to automate boring and repetitive stuff, but do not use it to draft your core messages and visuals,” Mittelmeier said. “This is your company DNA. You need to own it.”

Read the signal

For some investors, a bad AI pitch says more about the company than the financial metrics.

“The way founders use or may use AI to fundraise should reflect how they use AI in their products. It’s a great filter,” said Romain Serman, co-founder and GP at San Francisco-based VC Blue Moon. “If we think it’s bad, well chances are that the product will be bad, the go-to-market will be bad, how they interact with customers will be bad,” he said.

Serman’s partner at Blue Moon, Ben Orthlieb, has said he no longer relies on pitch decks anymore, instead fighting fire with fire: the firm uses its own machine-learning system that scores founders on 250 criteria.

Orthlieb said that VCs who discourage founders from using AI are missing the point. As AI helps founders refine their pitches, investors need to tweak their strategy and filtering tools.

“AI makes you able to focus on what matters,” Orthlieb said. “It frees your time to do those things that only humans can.”

An ineffective strategy

Several companies have emerged that offer AI fundraising tools to founders, and even they agree with VC critics, up to a point.

“I think what they’re correctly critiquing is that you can’t outsource your judgment and your thinking to AI,” said Usman Gul, founder and CEO of Metal, a startup that tries to match founders with VCs. Metal uses AI to create an investor memory layer, a database of a VC’s past deals, posts, and habits. The startup also has an email-generation tool, which Gul concedes could be used to flood investors’ inboxes, though he contends that founders aren’t using it for that purpose.

“Our platform can be misused,” he said. “Using it for efficiency is fair, but I think using it for mass outreach, that’s just not how venture markets work and it’s not likely to work.”

Vahid Fakhr, CEO and co-founder of Evalyze, another AI fundraising startup, acknowledged the same risk. “If AI only makes it easier to write and send emails, it can create more noise,” he said. AI, he added, “can improve the wording of a traction slide without improving the traction.”

That gap between polish and substance is what Orthlieb thinks investors should focus on. Rather than telling founders to stop using AI, he said, VCs should get clearer about what they’re actually judging.

“VCs have had the luxury of not having to be specific about what their criteria are,” Orthlieb said. “I think AI makes you able to focus on what matters.”

Recent News

Apollo views daily pricing as key to expanding alternatives access. Industry peers are skeptical.

Daily pricing is expensive, bureaucratic and risks giving individual investors a false sense of what their holdings are worth, critics say.

Slush investors point to hardware and deep tech for defensibility

Investors at Slush say AI is narrowing the gap between startups and incumbents.

Learn about our editorial standards.