wkndpitchimage10_13

Featured image by Megan Woodard/PitchBook News

Weekend Analysis

Will PE firms’ dividend recaps push bring more rewards or risks?

This year is set to see record levels of dividend recapitalizations—when a company issues debt in part to pay shareholders a dividend—which have come under fire recently

Over the summer I wrote about private equity’s intensifying debt dependence, from subscription lines to ManCo loans. However, one type of borrowing I didn’t delve into is quickly becoming the most controversial: dividend recapitalization.

A dividend recap—which is when a company issues debt so that all or some of the proceeds can be used to pay shareholders a dividend—has long been used by both public and private companies. However, in the case of the latter, usage has been ramping up.

Year-to-date dividend recap volume in the US for PE-backed companies, as of Sept. 24, stood at $69.3 billion, and this year’s annual total is expected to surpass 2021’s record high of $76 billion, according to PitchBook-LCD data.

In September, UK-based windscreen repair company Belron, which is backed by CD&R and Hellman & Friedman, launched the largest dividend recap ever, with plans to raise over €8 billion with €4.4 billion going to fund a shareholder dividend.

Now more than ever, such arrangements are raising eyebrows, with critics claiming that they benefit investors at the expense of the long-term health of portfolio companies. But does this criticism give an accurate picture of dividend recaps and their impact, or is the reality more nuanced?

All that glitters is not gold

Dividend recaps have historically been used more in periods of low interest rates and cheap debt, making this year’s surge seem atypical. However, a tough market for private equity-backed exits and increased pressure from LPs to return capital have made dividend recaps the tool du jour for liquidity-strapped GPs

While having the advantage of satisfying LPs’ needs in the short term, history has been littered with dividend recaps gone wrong. Creditors claimed that they were the cause of Bain Capital-owned KB Toys’ bankruptcy in 2012, while CI Capital Partners was sued by creditors following the collapse of restaurant chain Buffets for the same reason.

The main criticism lobbied at dividend recaps is that overleveraging portfolio companies can make them weaker and more susceptible to economic downturns.

As a greater share of a company’s cash flow is directed toward servicing debt , less goes towards growing the business. If cash flows weaken, the company may find itself unable to meet its debt covenants, increasing the risk of defaults and potential bankruptcy.

A National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) working paper released last month found that over a six-year period, dividend recaps made companies riskier, and increased the likelihood of bankruptcy—by 31 percentage points over six years, the researchers estimated.

In a real-world example, credit rating agencies Moody’s and S&P Global downgraded Belron into junk territory due to the recently proposed transaction, as it would almost double the company’s overall debt.

More than meets the eye

While dividend recaps do indeed heighten the risk of failure, that same NBER paper also found that they increase the likelihood of good outcomes.

The primary purpose of a dividend recap is to return capital to LPs without the need to sell an asset. PE firms can hold onto portfolio companies for longer than they otherwise could, giving them more opportunities to make operational improvements. It also allows the PE sponsor to wait for the right market conditions for an exit in order to achieve maximum results.

The paper also said that the increased leverage can introduce more financial discipline to the company’s management, leading to increased efficiency and better company performance.

For the PE sponsors, the pros of dividend recaps are more straightforward than for companies. By paying dividends, LPs are receiving capital earlier than they would if they were waiting for an exit, which boosts IRR.

By partially recouping their original investment, they are also lessening risk—they would lose less money if the company failed or its valuations declined before an exit. PE sponsors can lock in gains while still benefiting from any future growth of the portfolio company.

Furthermore, as the NBER paper pointed out, GPs tend not to raise their next fund while the interim performance of their current vehicle is weak.

The IRR boost that comes from a dividend recap can enable GPs to fundraise on an accelerated timeline and help attract new LPs for future funds by making them look more attractive—whether that is a positive for the existing fund is questionable.

Furthermore, PE firms tend to target larger and more profitable companies for dividend recaps, i.e. the companies that are more likely to bear the risk of an increased debt burden. However, there will be times when seemingly healthy companies find themselves overleveraged.

Anticipated interest-rate cuts are expected to lead to more exits eventually, but PE’s exit dilemma is unlikely to get much better in the short term—so it is a fair assumption that 2024 will end up as a record year for dividend recaps, even if the risks outweigh the good.

Featured image by Megan Woodard/PitchBook News

Learn about our editorial standards.