China has blocked Meta‘s $2 billion acquisition of Manus AI—a Singapore-based startup founded in Beijing—in an effort to stem outflows of Chinese talent and capital. Still, founders are just expected to find another workaround.
Referred to as “Singapore washing,” Chinese founders have increasingly navigated around investment restrictions by re-domiciling in the city-state and using it as a launchpad to access Western capital and buyers.
Manus AI launched its product in March last year, raising capital from Tencent, ZhenFund and HongShan Capital (formerly Sequoia Capital China). A month later, it raised $75 million from Benchmark Capital, and by June, it had moved its headquarters to Singapore.
Then, in December last year, just nine months out from its launch, it agreed to be bought by Meta. That deal has now been blocked by the National Development and Reform Commission, China’s top economic planning body.
The NDRC cited foreign investment laws, ordering both parties to withdraw from the deal on the grounds that the technology developed by Manus while it was still operating in China falls under national security and export controls.
Even with China’s blocking of the Manus AI deal, some VCs are not convinced it will deter Chinese tech founders from building in Singapore or elsewhere, be it Japan, Thailand or the US.
Investors say Chinese founders will simply get smarter about the entire process.
“I think this will push more Chinese founders to make a decision early on whether they will be a Chinese company focusing on the Chinese market or an international company on day one focusing on global markets,” said David Yin, partner at Informed Ventures.
Others agree. “The Singapore washing will continue, just in a different form or label. Chinese founders will likely start building in Singapore earlier instead of building in China before re-domiciling to Singapore,” added one Singaporean venture capitalist based in Shanghai, who declined to be named due to political sensitivities.
For now, there are costs to unwinding a transaction that has already been completed. According to the Financial Times, Meta would have to spin Manus AI off to a new buyer, sell it back to its former investors, or find new investors. The US tech giant had already begun integrating Manus into some of its tools.
This isn’t the first time VC portfolio investments have been caught in the crossfire between Washington and Beijing.
Just a few years ago, the US moved to limit investments into Chinese tech companies, culminating in several well-known Silicon Valley VC funds, including Sequoia Capital, GGV and Matrix Partners, spinning out their China operations.
But the capital hasn’t stopped flowing. It has just found new structures.
Bloomberg has reported that parallel fund structures granting US investors access to Chinese early-stage funds already exist and have been marketed by the likes of ZhenFund and Luminous Ventures.
For Chinese founders, the message from Beijing is clear. The response, it seems, is to get smarter, not to stop.
Learn about our editorial standards.