gettyimages-1027941602.jpg
Startups

Peloton founder bucks direct-to-consumer rout with new startup—selling rugs

A string of high-profile flops has soured investors on DTC startups. But serial entrepreneurs like John Foley are finding more success with the business model.

It’s a Silicon Valley truism that founders who have had success and notoriety with their first companies will have investors flock to their subsequent startups, even if those businesses are in a sector that is otherwise out of favor with VCs.

That seems to be the case with Peloton co-founder John Foley’s second act, a direct-to-consumer rug company called Ernesta, which just raised a $25 million Series A led by Addition and joined by True Ventures.

Ernesta, which will launch sales in spring 2023, plans to offer commercial and residential buyers affordable, high-quality custom rugs.

In the middle of the last decade, direct-to-consumer startups won over many venture capitalists. Companies that sold mattresses, cosmetics, clothing, glasses, and shoes online claimed that by cutting out the middleman and saving on physical retail space, they could offer consumers higher-quality, less expensive products.

But after a string of high-profile flops—such as home goods store Brandless, which nearly went out of business, and mattress retailer Casper, which was bought out by a PE firm after struggling as a public company—and a realization that the DTC business model isn’t as cost-effective as initially thought, investors have soured on the category.

Even Forerunner Ventures, a firm once seen as the leading investor in DTC brands, has shifted its focus to B2B ecommerce businesses, the firm’s founder and managing partner Kirsten Green told the Newcomer newsletter last year.

While few, if any, investors are expressly looking to back DTC startups now, VCs are making an exception for one started by a successful founder. With Foley, they are betting he can parlay his experience with Peloton into a lower-tech rug sales business.

“We are thrilled to be able to support his latest venture and look forward to watching him create magic again, this time in a whole new category,” Jon Callaghan, co-founder of True Ventures, said in a statement.

PitchBook’s recent analysis of serial entrepreneurs showed that they are more successful at attracting VC funding than first-time founders. As an example of this trend, Adam Neumann, who famously lost billions of investor dollars after WeWork initially failed to go public, has reportedly raised $350 million from Andreessen Horowitz for his next company, Flow, before launching the company.

Although Peloton’s stock price has dropped nearly 90% over the last year, Foley has created a popular, category-defining product with a market capitalization of over $3 billion today. Peloton’s workout equipment saw a surge in demand amid pandemic lockdowns, but consumer interest has waned after people regained access to gyms and exercise studios.

Featured image of Peloton co-founder John Foley by Kimberly White/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.