Aerial View of a Oil Refinery and Fuel Storage

Featured image by Chunyip Wong/Getty Images

Limited Partners

ExxonMobil board reappointed despite investor pushback

Shareholders have voted to keep ExxonMobil’s board in the face of opposition from some of the world’s biggest institutional investors.

A group of the world’s largest institutional investors have failed in their attempt to remove board members at ExxonMobil after a spat over shareholder rights.

The company’s annual meeting on Wednesday laid bare a showdown over the limits of shareholder activism and an ongoing global debate over the politicization of ESG-driven corporate governance.

In the end, 95% of ExxonMobil shareholders voted to retain the existing the board, defying a push by a group that included California Public Employees Retirement System and Norway’s Norges Bank Investment Management.

The group, which also included a number of state treasurers and New York City Comptroller Brad Lander, had been seeking to block the reappointment of several members, including lead director Joseph Hooley, after the energy company filed a lawsuit against activist shareholders. Illinois State Treasurer Michael Frerichs also urged investors to hold the company accountable for what the dissenters believe to be an infringement on shareholder rights.

The clash began in January when ExxonMobil filed a lawsuit against two activist groups, Arjuna Capital and Follow This, which had been pressuring the company to mitigate its greenhouse gas emissions.

Last week, a Texas judge ruled that the lawsuit could proceed against Arjuna Capital, despite the shareholder group having withdrawn their proposals in February. In response to the ruling, some institutional shareholders argued the lawsuit infringed on shareholder rights by threatening legal action against investors looking to submit shareholder proposals.

Calpers requested that ExxonMobil drop the lawsuit, arguing that the proposal is a well-established process that has provided shareowners a voice for decades.

“If successful, ExxonMobil’s lawsuit could empower more companies to take actions to silence shareholders on other issues they want to avoid discussing,” said Drew Hambly, Calpers Global Equities Investment Director, in a statement before the final vote.

At the annual meeting, ExxonMobil executives painted the shareholder campaign as social activists masquerading as stakeholders who were abusing the process to advance a political agenda.

Calpers said that while the shareholder resolution that sparked the lawsuit was to address climate change, the pension fund based its decision to vote against the company’s leaders in an effort to defend shareholders.

On the other side of the aisle, a group of officials from 19 red-leaning states, including Florida Chief Financial Officer Jimmy Patronis and Louisiana State Treasurer John Fleming, expressed support for ExxonMobil’s directors. In a letter to large money managers like BlackRock, Goldman Sachs and JPMorgan, the officials urged 19 asset managers to vote in support of ExxonMobil’s directors, arguing that the board deserves “thanks and support” for its actions against activist shareholders, who, the group argued, are politically motivated.

“We believe,” the letter said, “that if government entities use political pressure to substantially change the composition of the board of directors of a private company, a dangerous breach in the wall separating public and private spheres will occur.”

Featured image by Chunyip Wong/Getty Images

Learn about our editorial standards.