The combined factors of a tougher economic environment and a maturing industry are driving consolidation among private equity managers.
In this month alone, CVC Capital Partners bought infrastructure-focused manager DIF Capital Partners, and London-listed Bridgepoint picked up Energy Capital Partners, another infrastructure specialist, for an equivalent of $1.05 billion, including debt. The two deals happened within a day of each other.
Even larger firms have become targets of acquisitive peers. In May, TPG paid $2.7 billion for real estate and private credit heavyweight Angelo Gordon. At the end of last year, Sweden’s EQT bought Baring Private Equity Asia—one of the Asia-Pacific’s most well-established firms—in what is likely the biggest merger of its kind.
Fund manager mergers have long been a feature of the industry, but some in the industry expect them to accelerate. Such deals have many benefits for both parties. For the acquirer, they afford access to new markets and expertise; for the acquired, they can mean access to a bigger platform and an extensive investor roster. Meanwhile, LPs benefit from having their investment managed by a new entity that is feasibly better equipped to pursue new investment on their behalf.
Yet consolidation is a double-edged sword. While investors may be spared the tyranny of choice that comes with a saturated market, fewer players will be bad for competition and may eventually expose LPs to a higher fee burden and less diversification.
This article appeared as part of The Weekend Pitch newsletter. Subscribe to the newsletter here.
Growing consolidation is an almost inevitable consequence of a maturing market in which a small group of investors dominates fundraising. For the past decade that I have been covering the market, the industry has been going through a bifurcation, where capital has gravitated toward fewer multi-strategy asset managers commanding mega-funds with over $5 billion in commitments.
While the growing dominance of mega-funds seems to have eased—our Q2 Global Private Market Fundraising Report shows that year-to-date, such vehicles saw their share of PE fundraising value decline—they still command an outsized share of total fundraising, accounting for 36.8% of all commitments in the market. Meanwhile, funds over $1 billion represent nearly 79% of all capital raised.
At the same time, the managers overseeing many of these funds have become more acquisitive. According to PitchBook data, last year was a record year of merger activity between PE firms in terms of deal value, with $8.2 billion transacted across 10 deals. Even if you strip out EQT’s $6.6 billion acquisition, it remains the second-biggest year in terms of value and the fourth biggest year in overall deal count over the past decade.
This year, PE industry M&A activity has continued at a steady pace, with 10 deals worth $2.5 billion taking place. And more is expected. Last week, the CEO of private markets firm Partners Group, David Layton, told the Financial Times that the industry could be reduced to as few as 100 platforms in the coming years. He’s not alone: EQT’s CEO Christian Sinding made a similar prediction of accelerating industry consolidation in June.
Economics and politics are expected to help drive this activity. As higher interest rates hamper deal flow and more managers struggle with a tough fundraising environment and greater regulatory burdens—partly due to new SEC reporting requirements—that hit smaller firms the hardest, larger managers are seizing an opportunity to pick up struggling industry peers.
Not only do these deals allow managers to take advantage of new economies of scale by buying smaller and often more specialized managers, they are also getting access to new talent and expertise, new investment verticals, new geographies, as well as new investors.
There are potential downsides to consolidation. Even if larger managers have the financial resources to bring smaller firms onto their platform, integrating them is another matter. Expect culture clashes.
Moreover, a game with fewer players is less competitive, with consequences for LPs. As outsized platforms expand their market dominance, investors face the prospect of higher fees and less choice. Innovation could also suffer as new entrants into the market are discouraged.
Further down the line, financial watchdogs will inevitably be put on alert. Regulators such as the SEC have already been looking to rein in the PE industry with new requirements, and will almost certainly be perturbed by a proliferation of mega-managers. The upshot could be a backlash not unlike the one experienced by the tech industry.
Related read: PE firms are acquiring asset managers at record clip
Featured image by Mara Potter/PitchBook News
Learn about our editorial standards.