After months of quiet, the market for secondhand stakes in startups is starting to show signs of life.
2021 was a banner year for secondary deals. Investors of all types were willing to pay premium prices for shares of late-stage, high-growth companies. This year, however, trading of private stock between new investors and existing owners such as founders and employees came to a near-standstill when tech shares tanked.
Through Q2 and Q3, buyers and sellers had divergent expectations on pricing late-stage venture-backed companies. Prospective bidders waited to see how far prices would eventually fall. Meanwhile, many existing shareholders were poised to sell their stakes but were holding out to avoid steep discounts to the companies’ last valuation.
Now, secondary trading has finally started to rebound as sellers accept that valuations seen in 2021 are unlikely to return any time soon.
“I’m starting to see investors come back to the market because the bid and ask are meeting,” said Barrett Cohn, CEO and founder of Scenic Advisement, an investment bank that helps startup founders and early-stage investors sell their private stock on the secondary market. “Some of those investors are willing to trade at 40% to 60% discounts relative to 2021.”
By comparison, the market picture has been nothing short of bleak this year for newly public stocks trading on Wall Street. Year to date, the group was down nearly 60% in late November, according to the PitchBook VC-backed IPO Index.
Some companies’ shares are trading hands at as much as an 80% discount, said Brianne Lynch, head of market insight at EquityZen, a secondary trading marketplace.
When asked what kinds of companies are seeing such deep markdowns, Lynch declined to name specific companies, but noted that “there’s a lot going on in the crypto space and there’s been less interest there more recently that in the past.”
By contrast, business-focused software companies continue to command relatively healthy valuations, she said.
Big names take a dip
While trading is now more active than in early summer, the number of companies that garner any buyer demand is significantly lower than last year, said Greg Martin, a managing director at Rainmaker Securities, which specializes in shares of pre-IPO companies. He said that for many names actively traded last year, “it’s crickets now” among would-be buyers.
“But big companies represent big trading volume in terms of size,” Martin said. “There’s just not a lot of these.”
Martin said some well-known companies continue to trade with meaningful volume, including TikTok owner ByteDance, whose shares are down roughly 50% from 12 months ago.
Another cited by Rainmaker is payments specialist Stripe, which is trading at a 30% discount from its last funding round in early 2021, along with cybersecurity startup Arctic Wolf, which was valued at $4.3 billion in its last funding round. Meanwhile, SpaceX continues to buck the trend and commands a 5% to 10% premium.
A buyer’s market
The volume of shares being offered by sellers continues to greatly outweigh interest from buyers.
“There is a huge demand for liquidity from every company that comes to us,” Cohn said. “The supply side is unprecedented.”
Liquidity interest is high among founders, employees and VC backers of companies that had once planned to go public this year or early next year.
The need to sell is especially acute, Cohn said, among hedge funds that are exposed to “beaten up” public stocks and venture funds whose 10-year investment timelines are nearly complete. These investors are more willing than founders and employees to accept larger discounts.
New players
While institutional buyers are slowly coming back to scoop up secondary stakes, they aren’t the same players who were most active in this market last year.
Hedge funds and other crossover investors with significant public-market exposure are now largely selling rather than buying, according to several secondary brokerage specialists. Family offices are also a lot less active.
Rainmaker’s Martin said Middle Eastern sovereign wealth funds that benefited from strong oil prices have been busy shopping for shares of big brand names.
EquityZen’s Lynch said many traditional venture firms deploy capital into secondaries of strong companies at a discount because these companies aren’t raising primary funds now.
Despite the recent uptick in trading, volume has been very low by historical standards.
“In 2022, very little got done,” said Scenic Advisement’s Cohn. “It was a horrible, awful, terrible year.”
But he and others who concentrate on this corner of the market said they expect more activity next year. Employees and investors of companies planning IPOs in 2022 or early 2023 are demanding liquidity.
“We’ll help get broad-based liquidity for those folks,” said Cohn.
Featured image of Stripe co-founder and CEO Patrick Collison by Matt Winkelmeyer/Getty Images
Learn about our editorial standards.