02.12.25_Bradbury_Header Image (1).png

Featured images by Josie Doan/PitchBook News

Weekend Analysis

Trump’s CFPB shutdown makes consumer protection a selling point

When the federal regulators are gone, will fintechs make safeguarding consumers a marketing ploy?

The Trump administration’s decision to gut the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau will ripple across the fintech industry, shifting the onus of consumer protection from federal regulators to a patchwork of states.

Fewer enforcement mechanisms will likely invite more bad actors, some investors and lawyers predict. That could put more stress on companies that operate fairly and sustainably. For that group, consumer protection may actually be a new marketing moat.

Already, the Trump administration’s moves have put the agency’s staffers in limbo. CFPB headquarters were closed for the week, and 70 enforcement attorneys were terminated on Wednesday.

Meanwhile, ongoing lawsuits by Google and TechNet against the agency are on ice, as is a lawsuit against Zelle and several large banks that offer the digital payments service. The future of these cases, and of digital wallet regulation more broadly, is completely uncertain.

A new hot marketing strategy

Companies like buy now, pay later (BNPL) provider Affirm have integrated buyer protections into their products, and they’re unlikely to do away with them now. Instead, companies are likely to market these as benefits against competitors— a nice feature, rather than a given.

“The CFPB has set in motion a lot of safeguards that have been integrated into the products themselves, and now it’s a marketing necessity for competitors to match that,” says Matt Janiga, legal counsel at open payments company Trustly.

“It’s almost like fintechs may end up taking on more measures of consumer protection,” Janiga adds.

Financial institutions like that strategy, too. Capital One, for example, eliminated overdraft fees for consumer banking products a few years ago and almost immediately released TV ads touting the move.

Fines, fees, and bad actors

Critics of the CFPB say that it stifles innovation and overreaches its authority.

The CFPB’s headline-making fines—like its $175 million penalty against Block‘s handling of customer fraud and its $2.5 million fine to Wise over “deceptive fees"—are drops in the bucket for fintech companies of their size. But for early-stage fintech startups operating on razor-thin margins, “even a modest fine can drain your balance sheet,” says Janiga.

Few dispute that CFPB rules meaningfully impact financial services’ decision-making.

Take JP Morgan’s BNPL product: soon after the bureau issued its rule in 2024 that BNPL lenders had to offer the same safeguards as traditional credit cards, the bank announced it would stop consumers from using credit cards for BNPL transactions.

Without the CFPB, product managers may be less burdened by regulatory implications when releasing new apps and features. But that “creates opportunity for more bad actors in the space, and that does potentially shift the competitive landscape,” says Devon Kirk, general partner at fintech growth investment firm Portage Capital Solutions.

Back to the states

Dodd-Frank, the financial services regulation created in response to the global financial crisis of 2007-2009, still has teeth even without the CFPB.

“A completely gutted, inactive CFPB doesn’t take away the statutory rights of state agencies to bring federal claims under Dodd-Frank,” says James Kim, a former CFPB enforcement attorney and fintech partner at Troutman Pepper.

California, for one, has especially rigorous financial services rules. On Saturday, its earned wage access rule comes into effect, requiring providers to register and abide by the same rules the CFPB has put in place.

Without the CFPB, fintech companies won’t escape regulation. Instead, they’ll be left with a complicated patchwork of state agencies with varying standards and disclosure requirements.

“States have staffed up over the last eight years. They’re much larger offices,” says Eric Goldberg, partner at Akerman and former managing counsel at the CFPB. “But they can’t fill the gap entirely.”

Featured images by Josie Doan/PitchBook News

Learn about our editorial standards.