The venture capital market has already bottomed out, with signs that a gradual rebound is underway—but VC teams are still thinning out.
On the positive, valuations are in recovery and total deal value is at an eight-quarter high, hitting $55.6 billion, according to the Q2 2024 PitchBook-NVCA Venture Monitor released Thursday. At the time of writing, our European edition of the report has not yet been released; however, the Q1 2024 European Venture Report showed similar signs of recovery.
However, firms are still trimming the fat, and high levels of turnover reported in 2023 have continued in 2024, on both sides of the Atlantic Ocean. As recently as last week, Index Ventures cut five out of nine of its investors in San Francisco, Business Insider reported. Not long before that, we reported that UK-based Octopus Ventures cut 16% of its investment team.
Much of these dwindling headcounts can be put down to cyclical factors. Investment firms facing a difficult exit and fundraising environment must cut their cloth accordingly.
But there are also structural changes to consider: Technology is changing the way VCs work and putting pressure on existing business models. In a new era of generative AI, could slimmed-down investment teams become the new normal?
This is not the first time that VC staffing has fallen dramatically. Seasoned VCs like Christian Leybold, who founded Headline in 2003, can remember the investor extinction event that followed the dot-com boom at the turn of the millennium.
“Anecdotally, I would say around 60% to 70% of people who had a job in VC in 1999 didn’t have that job anymore in 2002,” said Leybold. " It’s normal for a period when funds are returning to normal size and managers are leaving the market.”
While we may not yet be experiencing an extinction event as acute as the dot-com crash, recent data shows VC headcount growth has slowed dramatically in the US. Growth in the number of investors at VC firms slowed to just 2% for the five quarters spanning Q1 2023 to Q1 2024. While there is no similar data in hand for Europe, our data has shown that there are 50% fewer active VC investors in the region.
“A lot of people staffed up between 2020 and 2022, and then the market fundamentally changed,” said Hussein Kanji, a partner at London-based Hoxton Ventures. “So people have started staffing down because they overhired, and they probably thought that they were going to grow into much bigger funds.”
However, Kanji adds that not all firms are trimming down, and some firms have even added to their team. Also, staff turnover is not necessarily correlated with performance. Index Ventures, which recently logged a successful $2.3 billion fundraise, is an example.
Alex Horkan, head of tech and high growth at London-based recruitment firm PER, notes that in many cases, VCs are being discreet about reducing headcount by encouraging employees to seek out other opportunities.
“People have been leaving the industry to go into operational roles, and sometimes that’s been their own portfolio companies,” he said. “We’ve seen a slowdown in more core, associate-level hiring.”
What is less clear how is long a recovery in the market will translate into a recovery in headcount. Horkan suspects there will be an increase in hiring in tandem with a fundraising recovery sometime in Q4, with a return to hiring levels seen around 2019.
However, there is the question of whether structural factors—such as the emergence of new technology—will have a more long-lasting impact. As more VCs adopt AI tools for aspects of their business, some are speculating whether a more permanent shift in headcount is likely as AI displaces some VC functions.
Headline’s Leybold does not think this is the case. He compared concerns of AI disintermediation to the fears of Initial Coin Offerings replacing traditional VC during the crypto boom. While AI might be useful tool, Leybold said there are aspects of venture investing that cannot be replaced.
“Ultimately, our business is about relationships. The best people in VC are the ones who can build trust very fast with entrepreneurs,” he said. “You will get a deal by building trust with an entrepreneur faster than other people do. And for that, you’re always going to need people—that is where the value is.”
Featured image by Megan Woodard/PitchBook News
Learn about our editorial standards.