The pandemic led to both an ecommerce boom and port shutdowns that together placed unprecedented pressures on the global supply chain, generating an opportunity for startups to step in with novel tech for industries like trucking, shipping and logistics.
One of those startups was Convoy. Billed as an “Uber for trucking” and backed by investors including Baillie Gifford, Greylock Partners, CapitalG and Bill Gates, Convoy hit a peak valuation of $3.8 billion in 2022.
But its success came to a grinding halt last week when the company ceased operations. On Thursday, CEO Dan Lewis told the company’s equity backers that the company was shutting down and exploring a sale—but even if they manage to make one, that its investors won’t get any money back, according to The Information.
Other supply chain tech darlings are showing strain. The CEO of Flexport, a freight forwarding company backed by Andreessen Horowitz and SoftBank, stepped down in September after just a year, and the company laid off 20% of its staff Friday.
As costs of capital rose, VCs scaled back their investments in supply chain tech solutions, and freight tech has been especially slow to bounce back, according to PitchBook’s Q2 2023 Supply Chain Tech Report. Average load sizes fell, but the price of diesel has kept rising, resulting in a cash crunch for many startups in the space.
“A number of these startups came in with a lot of confidence and a lot of swagger,” said PitchBook analyst Jonathan Geurkink. “It’s proving a quite bit harder to do what they envisioned.”
These four charts explain how the untangling of the supply chain shattered a tech industry dream.
The pandemic’s bottleneck on the global supply chain was exacerbated by a surge in online ordering, border control measures and stringent lockdowns on major ports such as China’s main commercial port in Shanghai.
Most of those impediments have been significantly lessened, if not resolved.
That’s no better indicated than by the supply chain pressure index published by the Federal Reserve of New York, which tracks the level of global supply chain disruption, incorporating factors including air freight cost indices, manufacturing delivery times, backlogs and purchased stocks. The supply chain was at its most strained during in 2021, but is now less constrained than the historical average.
All of those challenges were a tailwind for startups whose technology promised to remove friction in the supply chain.
In 2023, freight volumes have slumped and retailers have been less motivated to continue piling up inventory. Thus, carriers’ profits have fallen and the world has entered what Lewis described Thursday in a memo to Convoy’s employee’s as a “freight recession.”
As demand for freight has fallen, costs for carriers have stayed stubbornly high. The price of diesel, a critical input for carriers, has placed further financial burden on carriers, and has even driven some out of business entirely.
Those bankruptcies have further dampened the outlooks of startups like Convoy and Flexport that work at the intersection of truckers, manufacturers and retailers. The average truck is also carrying fewer goods, so the companies that match them to shippers are making less per transaction.
“If they had planned their business around $3,000 revenue per truck, a 50% haircut to that means your margin is going to be pretty crippling,” said Geurkink.
These businesses rely on high shipment volumes and new customer acquisition for growth. Flexport’s revenue reportedly fell 70% in the first nine months of 2023.
When spot rates—the prices that carriers charge shippers to move loads—spiked in 2021, it presented a lucrative opportunity for freight brokers like Convoy. But those prices quickly fell in 2022 and have been on the decline ever since.
Making less money on every transaction especially becomes a problem when a company has borrowed heavily to drive growth. Those credit lines continue to accrue interest as growth stalls.
In April 2022, Convoy announced a $100 million venture debt deal, as well as a new, $150 million line of credit from JP Morgan Chase to finance its operations.
As Convoy began to stare down a liquidity crunch, the most popular source of capital for startups in that situation—venture capital—dried up.
In Q2, supply chain tech companies secured $3 billion in VC funding across 190 deals, representing a 43% year-over-year drop in deal count and a nearly 70% drop in deal value, according to the report. For freight tech, the VC pullback is even more apparent. The segment is on pace to bring in less than 25% of the VC deal value it saw in 2022.
VCs are not entertaining disruptors in freight and last-mile delivery the way they had been in 2020 and 2021, perhaps recognizing that the Silicon Valley logic can’t always be applied to old-school, capital-intensive industries like freight.
Featured image courtesy of Convoy
Learn about our editorial standards.