Europe_ESG_Header Image.png

Featured image by Jenna O’Malley/PitchBook News

Weekend Analysis

The recalibration of ESG in Europe’s private markets

America’s rollback is giving the continent space to reflect on sustainability.

It has been a challenging year for ESG. Sentiment in the US has shifted away from supporting ESG initiatives in both private and public markets.

Major global banks, including JPMorgan Chase, Bank of America and Goldman Sachs, have left the Net Zero Banking Alliance in the past year after ESG-related initiatives in the US faced mounting political backlash. PE firms such as Carlyle and TPG this year removed significant language related to diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives from SEC filings.

Across the Pond, Europe also appears to be losing momentum in sustainability fundraising, which was on the cusp of becoming mainstream.

According to PitchBook data, a record €84.1 billion (about $98.3 billion) was raised in 2024 under the EU’s SFDR Articles 8 or 9 affiliations, increasing sixfold from just €13.7 billion in 2019. The proportion of funds classified at the Article 8 level of sustainability rose to 25.1%, the highest since the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation was first implemented in 2021.

However, as of July 3 this year, only €10.1 billion had been raised in Article 8 and 9 funds. Almost 95% of the capital raised was for other funds.

As Europe is left to find its own path amid an increasingly uncertain geopolitical and economic environment, is the ESG pullback a temporary correction or the start of a lasting decline?

A retreat

The politicization of ESG has led to a rise in greenhushing. Companies are deliberately choosing to downplay, underreport or avoid publicizing their genuine sustainability or ESG efforts, making data collection and decision-making more difficult.

“The US rollback can create a certain degree of fragmentation for European investors,” said Cristian Echavarria, head of regulatory services at Holtara, the ESG services arm of Apex Group.

“It affects stewardship dynamics, as US managers are less supportive and even oppose ESG resolutions. This forces European managers to either source information directly or adapt their fundraising approach in the US, where anti-ESG sentiment makes it safer to frame sustainability in terms of financial materiality and risk management rather than regulation.”

Finance has been modeling the potential risks of climate change for over 30 years, and that’s not going to stop now, regardless of the political mood music
Sally Kramers, UK Sustainable Investment and Finance Association

Another reason that ESG is being put on the back burner is the fiercer competition for capital. Besides its ESG backlash, the US has also adopted more protectionist policies aimed at shifting more investments into the country. Some European managers are scaling back their ESG efforts to make it easier for LPs to invest.

“Rather than the US increasingly catching up with Europe, the EU is pausing and aligning with them to get some investments back,” said Matt Smith, technical director, ESG transactions and sustainable finance at Anthesis, a sustainability consulting group.

With other priorities rising—including higher demand for value creation and distribution for LPs—it may appear that ESG is taking a backseat in the private markets in Europe. If this happens, GPs might risk a shrinking LP base and rely more on capital from less ESG-sensitive investors.

However, a perceived retreat could also be a recalibration of the developing ESG regime.

A recalibration

Although ESG faces increasing pressure, not all managers are retreating. According to Paula Langton, partner at placement agent Campbell Lutyens, current headwinds are mainly affecting a smaller segment of the market, highlighting a divide between GPs that are committed to sustainability and those who see it as a “nice-to-have.”

Langton of Campbell Lutyens added: "[Those affected are] what we call climate tourists, who maybe have come into the market more recently. We have had some questions about whether they should change their marketing to a non-impact fund so they can open up to more pots of capital. But generally, those are people who do not have a long track record in the space.”

A more common occurrence is a change in the manager’s ESG approach to adapt to the current environment.

This is twofold: recent extreme weather events have highlighted the importance of managing climate as a risk, while the volatile investment market has also prompted managers to improve value creation through sustainable investing.

Read more: Climate-focused PE funds are performing better than you think

“Finance has been modelling the potential risks of climate change for over 30 years, and that’s not going to stop now, regardless of the political mood music,” said Sally Kramers, head of industry development at the UK Sustainable Investment and Finance Association.

“Diversification is particularly key for funds [now] amid a tumultuous geopolitical landscape. A further focus is on risk management, which specifically considers potential climate and social issues.”

Real financial impacts are also crucial, as distributions and performance are now in the spotlight in the current fundraising market.

“ESG will increasingly be framed as a tool for value creation, risk management and resilience rather than a standalone selling point,” said Maria Merry del Val, director at Holtara.

A reflection

The backlash against ESG in the US has allowed Europe to consider what is effective and what needs to be changed.

The robust regulatory regime that initially gave Europe a head start has become more burdensome than some prefer. It demands executives’ time and effort to tick boxes instead of making a real difference.

The European Commission has been working to streamline regulations. In February, the EU’s executive arm adopted the Omnibus I package to simplify European rules on corporate sustainability reporting (CSRD) and due diligence (CS3D). The change excluded listed SMEs from the scope of the directives and raised the employee threshold to 1,000 and the turnover threshold to over €450 million.

On the CS3D, the threshold is increasing to 5,000 employees and €1.5 billion in net turnover.

If everything goes smoothly, this should improve the data quality to help managers make better decisions.

“Probably things will become more streamlined and simpler, and we will just provide data and information around what we need to provide. It will be rightly balanced so it does not get in the way of people taking action,” said Smith of Anthesis.

It is also worth reconsidering what will be included in the necessary dataset. Investors are increasingly focusing on tangible impact and seeing that their capital is helping to solve problems.

According to the Global Asset Owner Survey published by LP consultant bfinance in November, 26% of respondents planned to start impact investing—investments made with the intention of generating positive, measurable social and environmental impact alongside a financial return.

“Impact investing will get traction quicker than ESG because you are already starting from a baseline of understanding in ESG. But there are [still] issues we need to solve, and [impact investing] is tying the gap between the two,” said Sarita Gosrani, director of ESG and responsible investment at bfinance.

Given impact investing’s still-limited track record, how fast it will develop depends on how much risk investors are willing to accept. If Europe can seize the opportunity to develop a clearer and more tangible ESG framework, it could emerge from its relatively isolated path in sustainable investing stronger, more evolved and more mature.

Featured image by Jenna O’Malley/PitchBook News

Learn about our editorial standards.