As markets and valuations have fallen and interest rates have risen, structured equity has become more prevalent in the startup funding world, frequently used by investors and cash-strapped companies as an alternative to a traditional equity raise. Many such deals are structured with restrictive terms that have not been in use for years.
Structured equity, which often includes both equity and debt components, contains convertibles, debt with warrants, and preferred equity with or without warrants. It can be used to fund organic growth, finance acquisitions, or reduce leverage.
In a recent example of how structured equity is featured in funding rounds, corporate travel startup TripActions, which is planning an IPO, raised $304 million at a valuation higher than that of its previous round. The investment, which valued TripActions at $9.2 billion, included $150 million in structured financing provided by Coatue, reportedly coming from the firm’s new structured equity fund.
Chad Norman, a senior portfolio manager at Avenue Capital Group, said he is seeing a lot more insider-led financing rounds start as convertible debt, allowing companies to extend their liquidity runways without raising a priced equity round.
Many of these transactions include liquidation preferences and conversion discounts that grant noteholders the right to convert the loan at a 25% to 30% markdown from the purchase price in the next financing round, according to Norman.
Preferences, as they are known in the industry, entitle noteholders in a liquidity event the right to be paid back before common shareholders receive anything. In recent deals he is aware of, investors are more frequently asking for multiple liquidation preferences that grant investors the right to a return of at least two times their investments in a sale, Norman said.
Today, investors are far less concerned about valuations. Instead, they’re focused on getting terms that guarantee their returns, he added.
Fitness equipment company Tonal Systems, for instance, offered a two times liquidation preference to investors that funded its latest round during the summer, The Wall Street Journal reported.
The increasing use of structured financing in deals is yet another sign that the pendulum has swung in investors’ favor after the end of a long bull market during which founders, who often received more offers of financing than they needed, could cap investor returns or impose other terms.
Many investors have already sensed the shift and are taking advantage of it.
Earlier this year, a number of investors including Viking Global Investors, JP Morgan, and fintech-focused investor Portage were reportedly marketing structured equity funds targeting cash-starved startups. TPG, Insight Partners, Blackstone and Sixth Street are also among investors making structured equity investments, according to two people familiar with the matter.
Using structured financing in new fundraising rounds could come at the expense of common shareholders, including employees, and investors in earlier rounds.
“If you were doing that in Series A or Series B, you would expect investors in later rounds to have the same rights, and it would be very punitive to earlier-stage investors and certainly to founders,” said Vinny Pujji, a managing partner at Left Lane Capital.
Featured image by Brian A Jackson/Shutterstock
Learn about our editorial standards.